IMF Executive Board Discusses the Role of SDR
IMF News, April 11, 2018
Source details
- Canonical URL
- IMF Executive Board Discusses the Role of SDR
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: April 11, 2018
Overview
- Press Release No. 18/126
- Date: April 11, 2018
- On March 30, 2018, the Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) discussed a staff paper entitled Considerations on the Role of the SDR. The paper explores whether a broader role of the SDR could contribute to the smooth functioning and stability of the international monetary system (IMS).
- PRESS OFFICER: Phone: +1 202 623-7100 Email: MEDIA@IMF.org
Staff paper: scope and assessment
- Purpose: To assess whether a broader role for the SDR could help mitigate identified weaknesses in the IMS.
- Identified IMS weaknesses:
- A weak external adjustment mechanism.
- Gaps in international liquidity provision.
- Large-scale reserve accumulation.
- Conceptual forms of the SDR (three distinct forms):
- Official SDRs, the reserve asset administered by the IMF (O-SDR).
- SDR-denominated financial instruments, or “market SDRs” (M-SDR).
- The SDR as a unit of account (U-SDR).
- Historical note: The O-SDR was conceived under the Bretton Woods gold exchange standard as an international reserve asset to supplement existing reserve assets. The Second Amendment of the Articles of Agreement aimed to make the SDR “the principal reserve asset in the international monetary system,” but the SDR’s role as an international reserve asset has been limited.
- Uptake: Interest in both the U-SDR and M-SDR has been sporadic with low overall uptake.
Staff analysis and conclusions
- The staff analysis concludes:
- Among the three conceptual forms, the O-SDR has the greatest potential to contribute to the smooth functioning of the IMS under a different legal framework that would require amendments to the Fund’s Articles of Agreement.
- Major challenges for O-SDRs include scale, targeting, and the use of O-SDR allocations.
- Widespread M-SDR and U-SDR use would likely make more limited contributions to systemic IMS stability and face significant implementation challenges.
- The paper aims to initiate a conversation about the SDR’s role amid uncertainties from economic and technological developments, including:
- The prospect of a more multipolar global economy.
- The impact of financial innovation and new technologies.
Executive Board assessment — key findings and views
- General Director sentiment:
- “Executive Directors welcomed the opportunity to discuss whether the SDR could play a broader role in contributing to the smooth functioning and the stability of the international monetary system (IMS).”
- Many Directors noted the IMS had shown considerable resilience and strength, including during the global financial crisis (GFC); a few noted it had been further strengthened after the GFC.
- Directors noted ongoing challenges related to external adjustment mechanisms, gaps in official provision of international liquidity, and systemic side effects of large scale reserve accumulation.
- Most Directors were uncertain or unconvinced that there is a role for the SDR in addressing the weaknesses of the IMS; a number of Directors, however, saw potential and merit in continuing exploration.
- Views on expanded role of official SDRs (O-SDRs):
- Potential benefits discussed:
- Could help smooth external adjustment.
- Could augment the supply of safe global assets.
- Could reduce incentives for precautionary reserve accumulation.
- Reservations and concerns:
- Many Directors were not convinced that additional O-SDR allocations could effectively address IMS gaps.
- Many Directors noted the 2009 SDR allocation played an important role in mitigating the impact of the GFC.
- Concerns about moral hazard, including potential reluctance of some recipient countries to enact needed policy adjustments.
- A few Directors felt moral hazard concerns might be overstated and could be mitigated through increased transparency and effective surveillance.
- Doubts about whether voluntary trading participants would be willing to support high volumes of O-SDRs.
- Skepticism regarding alternative targeting mechanisms for SDR allocations (e.g., allocations contingent on global conditions or meeting policy criteria), with concerns that such mechanisms would blur the distinction between conditionality-based Fund lending and the role of the SDR as reserves.
- Many Directors noted such alternatives would require amending the Articles of Agreement and resolving operational considerations, such as the allocation of credit risk.
- Views on market SDRs (M-SDR) and SDR as unit of account (U-SDR):
- Most Directors saw limited scope for M-SDR and U-SDR to contribute to systemic stability.
- Uptake would be hard to achieve even with official sector support to reduce transaction costs and develop market liquidity and infrastructure.
- A number of Directors saw merit in exploring these issues further; a few called for a more active role for the Fund to contribute to the development of SDR market infrastructure.
- Economic and technological transitions:
- Directors welcomed a preliminary discussion on potential transitions such as a move toward a multipolar global economy and adoption of financial technologies, and their impact on the IMS.
- Most supported further analysis of how these developments could reshape the IMS in the future, noting:
- The role of the SDR either should not be the central question in this analysis or need not be explored at all.
- Staff should focus more on issues such as exchange rate adjustment, excess reserve accumulation, and global rebalancing.
IMF Executive Board Discusses the Role of SDR — Press Release No. 18/126 (April 11, 2018)