Israel: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2020 Article IV Mission
IMF News, November 19, 2020
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Israel: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2020 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: November 19, 2020
Overview and context
- The Israeli economy entered the COVID-19 pandemic from a position of strength, and the authorities mounted a large and rapid response to the crisis.
- Timely and decisive measures introduced by the Bank of Israel helped preserve market and financial stability and access to credit.
- Fiscal support to the health system, households, and businesses helped soften the economic impact of the pandemic.
- The outlook remains uncertain and dependent on the evolution of the pandemic; policies should continue to provide support, contain pandemic risks, and promote recovery.
Economic impact and outlook
- Real output has contracted less than in other advanced economies in 2020 and is projected to rebound in 2021, but a significant output decline is projected for the year.
- Unemployment, including those who were furloughed, is likely to remain in double digits.
- Greater unemployment among lower-income workers is likely to exacerbate Israel’s already high income inequality.
- Social distancing will likely continue to constrain domestic demand and drag GDP growth during the recovery.
Key pre-pandemic strengths and pandemic toll
- Pre-pandemic fundamentals:
- Real annual GDP growth: around 3¼ percent (last 5 years).
- Current account: averaged 3½ percent of GDP (last 5 years).
- Unemployment: 3.6 percent at end-2019.
- External debt: below 30 percent of GDP at end-2019.
- Net foreign assets: foreign assets exceeded foreign liabilities by 40 percent of GDP.
- International reserves: reached 33 percent of GDP.
- Pandemic impact by reported counts:
- More than 320,000 people have contracted the disease.
- 2,700 lives have been lost.
- Policy response scale:
- Several fiscal stimulus packages reaching 15¼ percent of GDP (of which 10¼ percent of GDP planned for 2020).
- Fiscal packages included support for healthcare, benefits for unemployed and furloughed workers, grants for self-employed and households, guaranteed loans for companies, and infrastructure support.
- Bank of Israel measures included asset purchase programs for government and corporate bonds, term funding to banks, foreign exchange operations, easing of macroprudential and supervisory requirements, and lower interest rates.
Risks
- Near-term evolution of the pandemic is the major risk to the economic outlook.
- Upside scenario: early wide-spread distribution of an effective vaccine would lead to a faster-than-projected recovery.
- Downside scenarios:
- Escalation of the pandemic could require prolonged containment measures and social distancing, bringing further disruptions to economic activity.
- Extensive fiscal support could limit fiscal space and create financing constraints.
- Failing to contain the pandemic could drain political capital and raise discontent.
- Geopolitical risks remain significant but have become more balanced after recent bilateral accords.
Fiscal policy: support, targeting, and medium-term consolidation
- Assessment of 2020 fiscal response:
- Fiscal expansion struck a balance between protecting the economy and preserving some fiscal space for future shocks.
- Support included urgent healthcare funding, transfers to households (mitigating impacts on aggregate demand and income distribution), and liquidity support for businesses.
- Near-term recommendations:
- Prompt passage of a 2021 budget to prioritize spending, position the economy for growth, and reduce economic uncertainty.
- Fiscal policy in the 2021 budget should remain supportive, especially if downside risks materialize.
- If the pandemic proves persistent and partial lockdown measures extend, consider:
- Additional funding for health services.
- Extending unemployment benefits beyond mid-2021.
- Further grants for the self-employed.
- Withdrawal of fiscal support should be timed carefully.
- Targeting and composition:
- Prioritize health spending to ensure adequate hospital capacity, testing and tracing, and other urgent needs.
- Gradually make fiscal support more targeted; discontinue blanket transfers and benefits while developing plans to bolster social protection.
- Greater focus on active labor market policies to improve job prospects for the unemployed.
- Support for businesses should target solvent companies.
- Public investment projects should focus on job-rich and inclusive projects.
- Medium-term fiscal effort:
- As the recovery strengthens and stimulus expires, effort will be needed to restore pre-crisis buffers.
- Higher debt accumulated during the crisis makes the debt trajectory more sensitive to new shocks.
- Tax reforms should be central: improving progressivity of income taxes and eliminating inefficient incentives and exemptions to raise Israel’s revenue ratio and address high income inequality.
Monetary and financial policy: accommodation with vigilance
- Monetary policy assessment:
- Decisive measures provided market liquidity and sustained credit flows to households and businesses.
- Measures eased early pressures on exchange rates, bond yields, and corporate spreads.
- Extending the current set of policies remains appropriate given low near-term inflation expectations, output projected to be below potential, and uncertainty about lockdown duration.
- Emphasis on asset purchases would keep term premia in check and preserve bond market functioning.
- Financial sector resilience:
- Banks have strong capital and profitability positions, supported by conservative business models.
- Relatively tight macroprudential policies prior to the pandemic provided space for policy relaxation.
- Banks have substantial capacity to face large and prolonged shocks even after recent release of capital buffers.
- Recommendation: unless further downside risks materialize, the level of minimum regulatory capital should not be lowered further, and structural buffers should eventually be restored.
- Managing support tapering and asset quality risks:
- Keep monitoring asset quality risks as borrower support measures are wound down.
- Continue financial sector support to hard-hit firms and households alongside monetary accommodation, but adjust modalities conditional on pandemic evolution.
- Gradually tighten eligibility criteria to target viable firms.
- Gradually restore banks’ discretion to defer household loans, subject to additional adjustments from pandemic-driven lockdowns.
- Prepare efficient and effective insolvency procedures, including adequate resources and mechanisms to implement the new Insolvency Law, to minimize barriers to corporate restructuring and spur productivity-enhancing capital reallocation in case of a surge in business insolvencies.
Structural policies for a resilient and inclusive recovery
- Objectives: limit long-term scarring, strengthen resilience, and promote inclusiveness through labor activation, human capital, and infrastructure investment.
- Labor market repair:
- Businesses in contact-intensive sectors furloughed the majority of their employees, accounting for half of all job losses.
- Part-time and low-skilled workers were more likely to be furloughed or dismissed.
- Well-funded labor activation policies (including vocational training) should facilitate reemployment, reskilling and upskilling, encourage job search, and reduce hiring costs.
- Expanding digitalization:
- The ICT sector’s high share in output contributed to resilience but is underutilized in many economic and social activities.
- Policies that broaden digital penetration can increase knowledge diffusion and productivity, mitigate skill shortages, and improve government service reach and effectiveness.
- Reforming education:
- Lockdowns created educational setbacks with potential lasting impacts on productivity and inequality.
- Planning, training, and investment in technology would ensure continuity and sustain education quality.
- Emphasize marketable skills (math, sciences, and technology) to prepare students for a more digitalized marketplace.
- Medium-term reforms that raise schooling achievement alongside Israel’s already high number of years of schooling would increase human capital, productivity, and living standards.
- Boosting investment:
- Public investment can create jobs, mitigate demand drops, and encourage private investment.
- Priority areas: health care, transportation, digitalization infrastructure.
- Closing gaps in reforming Israel’s government procurement system would enhance public investment management ahead of ramping up pandemic-related investment spending.
Acknowledgments
- The IMF team thanked interlocutors at the Bank of Israel, the Ministry of Finance, the National Economic Council, the Ministry of Health, the Israel Tax Authority, the Capital Markets, Insurance and Savings Authority, the Israel Securities Authority, and the private sector for constructive and fruitful discussions.
Staff Concluding Statement of the 2020 Article IV Mission, Israel: November 19, 2020.