Saudi Arabia - Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Mission
IMF News, May 3, 2021
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Saudi Arabia - Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: May 3, 2021
Mission assessment and immediate response to COVID-19
- Authorities responded quickly and decisively to the COVID-19 crisis with strict early containment and health mitigation measures; the vaccination program has advanced well in recent months.
- Fiscal, financial, and employment support programs introduced by the government and SAMA helped cushion the impact of the pandemic on businesses and Saudi workers.
- As the economy reopened, some support programs have been ended and others adjusted to target only those sectors where the effects of the crisis are longer-lasting.
- Reforms under Vision 2030—interagency coordination and governance, digitalization of government and financial services, labor market mobility reforms, and strong fiscal and financial buffers—helped the economy manage the crisis.
Economic outlook and key statistics
- Real GDP growth projections:
- 2.1 percent in 2021
- 4.8 percent in 2022
- -4.1 percent in 2020
- Real non-oil GDP growth:
- 3.9 percent in 2021
- 3.6 percent in 2022
- -2.3 percent in 2020
- Real oil GDP growth:
- -0.5 percent in 2021
- 6.8 percent in 2022
- -6.7 percent in 2020
- Unemployment rate for Saudi nationals:
- increased to 15.4 percent in 2020Q2
- declined to 12.6 percent in 2020Q4
- CPI inflation:
- 3.4 percent in 2020
- projected at 2.8 percent in 2021
- IMF staff view: economic recovery is ongoing; non-oil growth rebounded in H2 2020 and high-frequency indicators suggest recovery continued in 2021.
Fiscal policy — balancing short-term support and medium-term consolidation
- 2020 fiscal outcome and financing:
- Fiscal deficit widened to 11.3 percent of GDP in 2020 (4.5 percent of GDP in 2019).
- The deficit was comfortably financed by new borrowing and the drawdown of government deposits.
- IMF staff fiscal projections and medium-term outlook:
- Fiscal deficit projected to decline to 4.2 percent of GDP in 2021.
- Over the medium-term (by 2026) staff projects the fiscal position to move to broad balance given the global oil market outlook and government fiscal plans.
- Key contributors to planned fiscal adjustment that "should not be reversed or delayed":
- The VAT rate increase.
- The removal of the Cost-of-Living Allowances (COLA).
- Increased focus on the efficiency of capital spending.
- Planned further domestic energy price reforms.
- Short-term calibration recommendations:
- Consider a slower pace of adjustment this year to provide further support to the recovery by increasing spending on the social safety net.
- Increase spending on the social safety net to support low-income households and help offset loss of purchasing power after the VAT increase and COLA removal.
- The planned reform to move from a “categorial” to a “needs-based” system with a minimum guaranteed income is welcome, but increased support to low-income households should not await this transition.
- If the recovery stalls, the planned reduction in government capital spending could be slowed while keeping the medium-term capital spending envelope unchanged.
- There is fiscal space to increase healthcare spending if needed.
- Fiscal framework and risk management:
- Establishment of a high-level Sovereign Asset Liability Management Committee is an important step to manage the public sector balance sheet.
- Steps to strengthen fiscal transparency are needed, including publishing more detailed budget information and broadening coverage beyond central government.
- Fiscal risks should be monitored, including contingent liabilities from PPPs and credit guarantees in housing and SME programs.
- Etimad has strengthened government financial management.
- Government procurement could be further strengthened by removing remaining exemptions to the public procurement law.
Monetary, financial, and exchange rate policies
- Financial sector soundness:
- Banks are well-capitalized and liquid despite a decline in profitability and a slight increase in NPLs (which remain low) over the past year.
- SME support programs:
- Private sector support programs by SAMA and banks provided important breathing space to SMEs.
- The deferred payments program should be assessed regularly and withdrawn carefully; it likely masked financial vulnerabilities in some companies.
- Banks have increased provisions; SAMA should ensure banks carefully assess borrower creditworthiness, conduct stress-tests, and further increase provisioning if needed.
- Capital markets and debt market reforms:
- Continued pace of equity and debt market reforms under the Capital Market Authority and the National Debt Management Center.
- Developments cited: Aramco IPO in late-2019, inclusion in global equity and bond indices, introduction of equity derivative products, strengthened market infrastructure and regulation, foreign investors can directly trade domestic debt instruments.
- Government sukuk issuance has built-out a sovereign yield curve and liquidity in the sukuk market is increasing.
- Exchange rate policy:
- The exchange rate peg continues to serve Saudi Arabia well given the current economic structure.
- SAMA’s foreign exchange reserves remain at very comfortable levels.
Achieving strong, sustained, inclusive, and greener growth
- Structural reform priorities and potential impacts:
- Continue implementing structural reforms to secure strong, sustained, inclusive, and greener growth.
- Codifying legal practices will strengthen legal infrastructure for business.
- The PPP/asset sales program can increase the efficiency of capital allocation and service provision.
- Digitalization, e-government, e-commerce, and digital banking can boost productivity given the young and tech-savvy population.
- Ongoing initiatives to support SMEs and entrepreneurs are welcome; the fintech sector shows promise for SMEs and underserved groups.
- Role of public sector interventions:
- Public sector interventions can help overcome private-sector reluctance to enter new or riskier sectors, but must be carefully implemented to avoid crowding-out private investment.
- Where the public sector is involved, announce a timeframe for involvement to end (the PIF Board has said 5 years) and put in place a plan for eventual exit to allow greater private involvement.
- Potential effects of scaling-up domestic investment on fiscal and external accounts need careful analysis.
- Green growth and GHG emissions:
- The Saudi Arabia Green Initiative is a welcome commitment to reduce GHG emissions; more specific plans on how commitments will be met are needed.
- Continue reducing domestic energy price subsidies and step-up green investments to boost growth, employment, and reduce GHG emissions.
- Renewable energy potential is large and should attract domestic and foreign investors given the right regulatory and financial environments.
Labor market, human capital, and competitiveness
- Female labor force participation and Kafala reforms:
- Saudi female labor force participation rate is estimated to have increased by 13 percentage points to over 33 percent over the past two years.
- This increase will help boost productivity, growth, and household incomes as these women become employed.
- Reforms to the Kafala sponsorship system for expatriate workers in the private sector are very important; with strong enforcement, new regulations will give foreign workers greater freedom of movement, benefiting wages and productivity.
- Competitiveness of Saudi workers:
- Increasing competitiveness requires aligning wage expectations of Saudi workers with productivity.
- Policy focus should continue on improving education and vocational training to boost productivity.
- Experience with e-learning during the pandemic may offer new options for broadening education and training.
- A clear policy message that future public sector job opportunities will be limited can reduce the reservation wage of Saudi workers.
Policy recommendations — prioritized
- Maintain the commitment to medium-term fiscal consolidation while calibrating short-term support:
- Consider slowing the pace of consolidation this year to support recovery by increasing social safety net spending.
- Do not reverse or delay the VAT increase, COLA removal, efficiency of capital spending measures, and planned energy price reforms.
- Social protection and healthcare:
- Increase social safety net spending immediately to help low-income households; do not wait for the transition to a needs-based system.
- Preserve medium-term capital spending envelope but consider slower near-term cuts if recovery stalls.
- Increase healthcare spending if needed.
- Financial sector normalization and supervision:
- Withdraw deferred payment programs carefully and base decisions on regular assessments of SME and macro-financial conditions.
- Continue bank stress-tests and provisioning as vulnerabilities are revealed.
- Structural and market reforms:
- Continue legal, capital market, and debt market reforms to expand private investment and financing options.
- Strengthen fiscal transparency and procurement processes; monitor PPP and guarantee-related fiscal risks.
- When public sector invests to catalyze new sectors, announce exit timeframes and exit plans (PIF Board has said 5 years).
- Green transition:
- Translate the Saudi Arabia Green Initiative into specific implementation plans and stepped-up green investments.
- Continue energy subsidy reforms and create regulatory and financial environments to attract renewable investment.
- Labor market and human capital:
- Continue reforms to increase female labor force participation and labor mobility for expatriates.
- Improve education and vocational training and communicate limits on future public sector employment to lower reservation wages.
Mission team thanks the Saudi Arabian authorities and the people they met outside the government sector for their cooperation and open discussions.