Spain: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2022 Article IV Mission
IMF News, November 23, 2022
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Spain: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2022 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: November 23, 2022
Economic Outlook
- Spanish economy recovering from the COVID pandemic but facing new headwinds from Russia's invasion of Ukraine and higher global energy and food prices in 2022.
- Unprecedented public support measures in 2020–22 helped protect firms and households.
- Labor market: employment exceeded its pre-pandemic level in 2022; tourism and other services performed especially strongly.
- Inflation:
- Headline inflation declined from double-digit levels in the summer to 7.3 percent in October.
- Core inflation remains elevated at around 6 percent.
- No clear signs of a wage-price spiral so far, though the share of workers covered by wage agreements with indexation clauses has ticked up.
- Terms-of-trade: higher imported energy prices constitute a negative terms-of-trade shock requiring absorption via temporarily lower real incomes for households and firms; a broad income-sharing agreement (pacto de rentas) could reduce inflation persistence risk.
- Growth projections:
- 4.6 percent in 2022.
- 1.2 percent in 2023.
- Output projected to reach its pre-pandemic level by early 2024.
- Inflation outlook: headline and core inflation likely to remain above the 2-percent target until 2024.
- Uncertainty: risks mostly to the downside — possible further energy price increases, more abrupt global slowdown, or sharper tightening of financial conditions; upside risk from faster unwinding of households’ accumulated excess savings.
Energy Policies
- Public support mitigated the energy-price shock but greater targeting is desirable.
- Appropriately targeted measures: expansion of electric and thermal social bonds, increase in minimum vital income, sectoral direct aid for firms, innovative cash-transfer program for lower-income households not covered by minimum vital income.
- Less targeted measures: electricity tax reductions and fuel rebates — fiscally costly and disproportionately benefit higher-income households.
- Iberian mechanism lowers electricity prices without fiscal cost but reduces incentives to adjust demand.
- Policy recommendations:
- Prefer direct transfers (e.g., lump-sum vouchers linked to income or household size) over price-reducing measures.
- Consider block tariffs and/or further expand social tariffs (discounts for vulnerable households such as the Spanish bono social).
- Make measures more progressive by recouping support from higher-income households through the tax system.
- Keep corporate support measures targeted.
- Over the medium term, accelerate reduction of fossil fuel dependency and increase energy efficiency for sustainable energy-price reductions and energy security.
Fiscal Policies
- Public finances improved in 2022, but public debt remains high.
- Public debt was 118 percent of GDP at the end of 2021.
- Expected fiscal deficit reduction in 2022 driven by strong revenues and withdrawal of Covid measures, offsetting energy measure costs.
- Revenue performance supported by recovery in activity, high inflation, buoyant labor market, and relatively high elasticity of revenue to output (possibly temporary).
- Near-term pressures:
- Inflation impact on expenditure items (e.g., pension payments) will materialize in the next year.
- Energy support likely to extend into 2023.
- Rising interest rates will increase debt-service share over time.
- Long-term strain from rising age-related spending due to demographics.
- Fiscal consolidation guidance:
- Begin discretionary fiscal consolidation in 2023 to boost investor confidence and contain inflationary pressures.
- Recommend a moderate reduction in next year’s primary structural fiscal deficit—by one quarter to one half percentage point of GDP.
- Draft budgetary plan envisages a reduction of the structural deficit by 0.3 percentage points.
- Increasing consolidation to at least 0.6 percentage points per year starting in 2024 would set debt on a firm downward path and help achieve a close-to-balanced structural fiscal position by the end of the decade.
- Consolidation should be guided by the reformed EU fiscal framework once implemented.
- Temporary revenue measures and monitoring:
- Budget proposes temporary taxes on corporations and high-income households to fund support for the most vulnerable.
- New levies for energy and banking sectors are applied on revenues instead of profits; these do not take costs into account.
- Need to monitor impacts of levies on credit availability, credit costs, banks’ resilience, and incentives for energy companies to invest.
- These measures should remain temporary and not substitute for necessary medium-term tax reform.
- Medium-term reforms:
- Fiscal consolidation should rely on mobilizing additional revenues and enhancing spending efficiency.
- Revenue reform to broaden tax bases and strengthen environmental taxes, in line with the expert review of Spain's tax system.
- Measures disproportionately affecting low-income populations should be accompanied by targeted protection.
- Strengthen carbon pricing in the future when global fossil fuel prices decline.
- Use spending reviews by the fiscal responsibility authority (AIREF) to guide spending efficiency.
- Pensions:
- 2021 pension reform permanently indexed pension payments to CPI and repealed the sustainability factor.
- Reform expected to raise annual pension outlays by more than 3¼ percent of GDP by 2050 compared to full implementation of previous legislation.
- 2022 measures include reform of contribution system for the self-employed and commitments to additional reforms (extend computation period for retirement pension calculation and raise maximum earnings subject to contributions); sufficiency for sustainability depends on design details.
Financial Policies
- Financial sector performance:
- Private-sector balance sheets have strengthened; aggregate borrower stress indicators remained low in 2022 so far, including for publicly-guaranteed pandemic loans.
- Credit risks have increased for firms affected by the energy crisis and for lower-income households with less accumulated savings.
- House prices accelerated over the last year, but no evidence of significant misalignment with fundamentals so far.
- Activation of sectoral macroprudential tools not necessary at the moment, but rising housing prices warrant close vigilance.
- Interest-rate exposure and borrower vulnerability:
- About 75 percent of all mortgages are variable-rate, exposing borrowers to rising interest rates.
- Higher interest rates will increase firms’ financial burden, more severely affecting SMEs.
- Mitigating factors: many recent mortgages at fixed rates, majority of publicly-guaranteed pandemic loans fixed rate, strengthened lending standards since the great financial crisis, and significant household and corporate deleveraging.
- Mortgage relief measures under discussion should be targeted to the most vulnerable households.
- Bank resilience and supervision:
- Banks frontloaded provisioning during the pandemic; provisioning levels should remain forward-looking given new headwinds.
- Stress tests suggest bank capital buffers remain broadly adequate, but close monitoring is needed.
- Banks should factor the new macroeconomic context into capital planning and use near-term positive interest-rate impacts on profitability to strengthen resilience if needed.
- If adverse risk scenarios materialize, banks should be encouraged to use capital buffers and allowed to restore them gradually.
- Recent reform to the private debt resolution framework is comprehensive and aligns with the European Directive; strong implementation and sufficient judicial resources are critical.
Structural Policies
- Productivity and inclusiveness:
- Spain’s levels and growth rates of labor productivity have been lower than in peer economies, hindering income convergence.
- Productivity underperformance is broad-based across sectors, pointing to cross-cutting drivers: prevalence of SMEs, high incidence of temporary employment, and skill mismatches.
- Recovery-plan reforms:
- Ambitious structural reform agenda aims to reduce barriers to productivity growth.
- Examples: vocational education and training reform to boost skills for green and digital transition; Startup and Business Growth Laws to reduce financial and administrative barriers to firm creation and growth.
- Success depends on design and implementation; establish regular, data-driven, outcome-based evaluation of reforms’ effectiveness.
- Address size-dependent regulatory thresholds and regulatory differences across regions to support firm growth.
- Labor-market reforms:
- December 2021 labor reforms are increasing permanent employment with a significant shift from temporary to permanent contracts in 2022, though it is early to assess full impact.
- Continue monitoring to ensure reforms increase employment stability while preserving firm flexibility.
- Revamp active labor market policies (ALMPs) to improve labor matching and address skill mismatches.
- Success of new Employment Law and hiring-subsidy reforms depends on their ability to reduce Spain’s high structural unemployment; outcome-based evaluation is critical.
- NGEU funds:
- Use of NGEU funds is gaining speed; awarding of tenders and transfers to regional authorities and public entities accelerated in 2022.
- Lack of systematic and comprehensive information on execution, including in national accounting terms, hampers assessment of resources reaching the real economy.
- Improve coordination across government levels and with the private sector and enhance collection and reporting of data on investment execution to ensure effective use of funds.
International Monetary Fund — Staff Concluding Statement of the 2022 Article IV Mission for Spain