Inside the World of Global Tax Havens and Offshore Banking
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Inside the World of Global Tax Havens and Offshore Banking
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: JANNICK DAMGAARD, THOMAS ELKJAER
- Published: June 1, 2018
- Volume: 55
Scale and nature of offshore corporate investment
- New research finds multinational firms have invested $12 trillion globally in empty corporate shells.
- That $12 trillion represents almost 40 percent of all foreign direct investment positions globally.
- Eight major pass-through economies host more than 85 percent of the world’s investment in special purpose entities: the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Hong Kong SAR, the British Virgin Islands, Bermuda, the Cayman Islands, Ireland, and Singapore.
- Characteristics of these special purpose entities: legal registration subject to national law; ultimate ownership by foreigners; few or no employees; little or no production in the host economy; little or no physical presence; mostly foreign assets and liabilities; group financing or holding activities as core business.
- The use of pass-through entities is growing, driven by increasing complexity of corporate structures and expanding FDI positions vis-à-vis financial centers.
- Country-level prevalence:
- In emerging market economies such as India, China, and Brazil, 50 to 90 percent of outward foreign direct investment goes through a foreign entity with no economic substance.
- In advanced economies such as the United Kingdom and the United States, the share is 50 to 60 percent.
- Global average is close to 40 percent.
- Implications: while pass-through entities do not in themselves prove tax avoidance, they create opportunities for aggressive tax minimization and are associated with lower effective tax rates for multinational firms with a nominal presence in tax havens.
Scale and distribution of private offshore wealth
- Individuals hold about $7 trillion in offshore accounts globally.
- That $7 trillion corresponds to roughly 10 percent of world GDP.
- Offshore personal wealth as percent of national GDP varies widely:
- About 4 percent of GDP in Scandinavia.
- About 50 percent in some oil-producing countries, such as Russia and Saudi Arabia.
- About 50 percent in countries that have suffered major financial instability, such as Argentina and Greece.
- Patterns suggest:
- High domestic tax rates are not necessarily associated with high levels of offshore personal wealth (Scandinavia example).
- Offshore accounts can be used for reasons other than tax evasion, including circumventing capital controls during currency crises and laundering proceeds from corruption in resource-extraction industries.
Shifts in the global wealth-management market
- The share of the world’s hidden wealth managed by Swiss banks has dropped from almost 50 percent on the eve of the financial crisis to about 25 percent today.
- Expansion of Asian tax havens such as Hong Kong SAR, Macao SAR, and Singapore is associated with this shift.
- Possible interpretations: increased international cooperation by traditional European tax havens deterring tax evasion, and/or a larger share of the superrich being Asian and using nearby tax havens.
Policy context and enforcement initiatives
- Recent policy initiatives introduce new reporting and information-exchange requirements, including FATCA, CRS, and BEPS.
- Multinational firms must report country-by-country information about their economic activity.
- Banks must conduct thorough background checks of customers to identify foreign-owned accounts and report detailed account information to tax authorities.
- Tax authorities must share tax-relevant information with foreign counterparts through comprehensive information exchange agreements.
- Debate: some view these initiatives as necessary to fix a broken international tax system; others argue enforcement costs could dwarf benefits. Reliable measures of offshore scale are essential to weigh these views.
Data gaps and recommended statistical improvements
- Existing analyses are based on incomplete evidence because multinational firms and individuals can use additional methods to shelter wealth abroad.
- Recommended data actions:
- More countries should regularly report detailed financial data broken down by instrument, domestic sector, counterpart sector and country, currency, and maturity.
- Supplement traditional macroeconomic statistics with data on global interconnection that look beyond holdings of financial wealth across borders to find ultimate owners.
- Rationale: richer, detailed, and reliable evidence is necessary to weigh costs and benefits of policy initiatives addressing offshore financial secrecy.
Source: Inside the World of Global Tax Havens and Offshore Banking - F&D Magazine, June 2018
Content in this bundle
- كشف النقاب
- Inside the World of Global Tax Havens and Offshore Banking - IMF F&D Magazine - June 2018
- Correr el velo ● El dinero se transforma ● Finanzas y Desarrollo ● Junio de 2018
- Lever le voile
- Снимая завесу – Финансы и развитие – июнь 2018 года
- 揭开面纱 - 金融与发展
- The Global FDI Network: Searching for Ultimate Investors, WP/17/258, November 2017