9/15/2017 UPDATE: French and Spanish translations of our recent draft, The Taxation of Offshore Indirect Transfers – A Toolkit, are now available for comment. To give our colleagues who work in those languages a full opportunity to give us their feedback, we have extended the comment period to October 20th, 2017.
The Platform for Collaboration on Tax – a joint initiative of the
International Monetary Fund (IMF), OECD, United Nations and World Bank
Group – is seeking public feedback on a draft toolkit designed to help
developing countries tackle the complexities of taxing offshore indirect
transfers of assets, a practice by which some multinational corporations
try to minimize their tax liability.
The tax treatment of ‘offshore indirect transfers’ (OITs)—the sale of an
entity located in one country that owns an “immovable” asset located in
another country, by a non-resident of the country where the asset is
located—has emerged as a significant concern in many developing countries.
It has become a relatively common practice for some multinational
corporations trying to minimize their tax burden, and is an increasingly
critical tax issue in a globalized world. But there is no unifying
principle on how to treat these transactions, and the issue was not
addressed in the G20-OECD project on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting
(BEPS). This draft toolkit, “The Taxation of Offshore Indirect Transfers –
A Toolkit,” examines the principles that should guide the taxation of these
transactions in the countries where the underlying assets are located. It
emphasizes extractive (and other) industries in developing countries, and
considers the current standards in the OECD and the U.N. model tax
conventions, and the new Multilateral Convention. The toolkit discusses
economic considerations that may guide policy in this area, the types of
assets that could appropriately attract tax when transferred indirectly
offshore, implementation challenges that countries face, and options which
could be used to enforce such a tax.
The toolkit responds to a request by the Development Working Group of the
G20, and is part of a series the Platform is preparing to help developing
countries design their tax policies, keeping in mind that those countries
may have limitations in their capacity to administer their tax systems.
Previous reports have included discussions of tax incentives, and external
support for building tax capacity in developing countries. This series
complements the work that the Platform and the organizations it brings
together are undertaking to increase the capacity of developing countries
to apply the G20-OECD Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) project.
The Platform partners now seek comments by October 20, 2017 from all
interested stakeholders on this draft. The Platform aims to release the
final toolkit by the end of 2017.
Questions to consider
1. Does this draft toolkit effectively address the rationale(s) for taxing
offshore indirect transfers of assets?
2. Does it lay out a clear principle for taxing offshore indirect transfers
of assets?
3. Is the definition of an offshore indirect transfer of assets
satisfactory?
4. Is the discussion regarding source and residence taxation in this
context balanced and
robustly argued?
5. Is the suggested possible expansion of the definition of immovable
property for the purposes of the taxation of offshore indirect transfers
reasonable?
6. Is the concept of location-specific rents helpful in addressing these
issues? If so, how is it best formulated in practical terms?
7. Are there other implementation approaches that should be considered?
8. Is the draft toolkit’s preference for the ‘deemed disposal’ method
appropriate?
9. Are the complexities in the taxation of these international transactions
adequately represented?
Please do not restrict yourself to these questions; any other views you
have on addressing the taxation of offshore indirect transfers of assets
would be welcome. Comments and inputs on the draft will be published, and
will be taken into consideration in finalizing the toolkit.
Spanish and French language versions of the toolkit are forthcoming and
will also be posted for comment.
Comments should be sent by e-mail no later than October 20, 2017 to
taxcollaborationplatform@worldbank.org, a common comment box for all the Platform organizations.
Please note that all comments received will be made publicly available.
Comments submitted in the name of a collective “grouping” or “coalition”,
or by any person submitting comments on behalf of another person or group
of persons, should identify all enterprises or individuals who are members
of that collective group, or the person(s) on whose behalf the
commentator(s) are acting.
Media queries should be directed to:
IMF: media@imf.org
OECD: Pascal Saint-Amans, Pascal.Saint-Amans@oecd.org
UN: Alexander Trepelkov, trepelkov@un.org
World Bank Group: Julia Oliver, joliver@worldbankgroup.org