Washington, DC: An International Monetary Fund (IMF) team, led by Mr. Papa N’Diaye, Mission Chief for the Republic of Botswana and head of the African Department Regional Studies Division, held virtual discussions on the 2020 Article IV consultation from March 8-23, 2021. At the conclusion of the discussions, Mr. N’Diaye issued the following statement:
“Botswana entered the COVID-19 crisis with larger buffers and lower public
debt than other countries in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), but significantly
less than in the past. The country was contending with structural
challenges, persistent negative external shocks and delays in adjustment
that caused a weakening of international reserves and the fiscal position
amid high unemployment.
“The pandemic exacerbated Botswana’s economic challenges. While strict
containment measures helped to limit the spread of the virus and save
lives, the heavy economic reliance on diamonds and contact-intensive
activities caused a sharp GDP contraction, one of the deepest in SSA. The
current account deficit widened and foreign exchange reserves dropped
further, though remaining above adequate levels. The government implemented
a sizeable public wage increase agreed in 2019 and deployed an economic
relief package to counter the effects of the COVID-19 crisis. The relief
package helped save people’s livelihoods.
“In this context and despite a second wave of COVID-19 infections, a
recovery is underway, with GDP growth expected at 8.3 percent in 2021,
driven by a strong rebound in mining activity, the easing of restrictions
on mobility, and the recent public wage increase. The fiscal and external
positions are expected to strengthen gradually along with favorable terms
of trade. However, uncertainty is high, and risks are dominated by the
evolution of the pandemic and vaccine rollout in Botswana and globally, and
lower-than-expected diamond revenue. At the same time, a steadfast
implementation of supply-side reforms could promote private sector activity
and diversify the sources of growth.
“The first priority remains securing and ensuring successful rollout of
vaccines to a share of the population large enough to keep the pandemic
under control and prevent health systems from being overwhelmed.
“The next priority is to enhance Botswana’s resilience to shocks and
advance supply side reforms to promote private sector activity and
diversify its sources of growth. In this context, the mission commends the
commitment to fiscal sustainability and recommends that the adjustment
planned in the draft FY2021/22 budget be implemented without further
delays. Under the baseline, the envisaged pace and size of consolidation
and shift in spending composition are appropriate. The gradual reduction of
the fiscal deficit will put the fiscal position on a sustainable footing,
while targeted investment and human capital development could raise
productivity, create jobs, and help diversify the economy and revenue
sources. At the same time, the envisaged incentives for training and
financial support to transformative sectors will facilitate the
reallocation of factors to new sectors.
“There is a need to maintain targeted support to illiquid but solvent firms
and affected households and make the support state-contingent or
conditional to reduce moral hazard. This will help address the uneven
nature of the recovery across sectors and mitigate the regressive impact of
planned increase in the VAT rate and other taxes and fees on the most
vulnerable. Given the uncertainty on the evolution of the health crisis and
mineral revenue, the mission is of the view that the recommended targeted
support would need to be financed through both revenue and expenditure
measures.
“Fiscal reforms are needed to lock-in consolidation efforts. They include
civil service reform, acceleration of plans to rationalize the parastatal
sector and improve its governance, and a strengthening of the fiscal
framework to better anchor fiscal policy and increase credibility. In
addition, mobilizing domestic savings to finance the deficit requires
coordinated efforts to deepen the bond market.
“Beyond fiscal policy, the accommodative monetary policy stance is
appropriate and should be maintained, while carefully monitoring
second-round effects from supply shocks to inflation and inflation
expectations, as well as credit developments.
“The mission welcomes the recently increased crawl rate of Botswana’s
exchange rate peg, which has helped the economy adjust to the COVID-19
shock. Going forward, Bank of Botswana should use the flexibility afforded
by its current exchange rate regime to help the economy adjust to shocks,
ensure external viability, and facilitate structural transformation.
“The authorities’ interventions also helped to mitigate immediate
macro-financial risks. As the health crisis wanes, COVID-19 related
forbearance measures should be unwound, adequate liquidity maintained in
the domestic market, risks closely monitored. Building on recent progress
in addressing AML/CFT deficiencies is a priority.
“Decisively implementing the ERTP will diversify the sources of growth and
promote private sector activity thereby creating jobs. Successfully
implementing this strategy requires its continuous appraisal of existing
sectoral programs, assessment and adaptation to changes in domestic and
external markets, focusing on promising sectors, tackling market and
government failures, and addressing key bottlenecks as needed (small scale,
mismatched skills, lack of competition, coordination failures, information
asymmetries).
“We would like to thank the authorities for excellent discussions and
support during the Article IV consultation.”