Lebanon: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission
IMF News, March 23, 2023
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Lebanon: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: March 23, 2023
Mission assessment — economic and social conditions
- Lebanon is facing an unprecedented crisis with severe economic dislocation, a dramatic depreciation of the Lebanese lira, and triple-digit inflation that have had a staggering impact on people’s lives and livelihoods.
- Unemployment and emigration have increased sharply, and poverty is at historically high levels.
- Provision of basic services (electricity, public health, public education) has been severely disrupted; essential social support programs and public investment have collapsed.
- Capacity in public administration has been critically weakened.
- Banks are unable to extend credit to the economy and bank deposits are mostly inaccessible to customers.
- The presence of a large number of refugees exacerbates Lebanon’s challenges.
Key macroeconomic indicators and trends (as reported)
- Economic contraction: "about 40 percent since the start of the crisis."
- Inflation: "triple digits."
- Budget deficit: "over 5 percent of GDP" (noting it could be higher if central bank quasi-fiscal operations are included).
- Current account deficit: "estimated to have widened significantly to over 25 percent of GDP in 2022."
- Foreign reserves: "about US$ 10 billion as of December 2022 (excluding gold), compared to US$36 billion prior the crisis."
- Drivers of 2022 developments: some recovery in tourism, further deleveraging of the corporate sector, and continued strong remittances inflows supporting consumption.
Risks and consequences of inaction (status quo)
- Continued high poverty and unemployment; declining economic potential.
- Further erosion of trust in institutions and deeper weakening of the external position.
- Continued loss of BdL international reserves.
- Ongoing exchange rate depreciation and spiraling inflation, accelerating cash dollarization.
- Increased informality of the economy, reduced tax base, depressed budgetary spending, and heightened risk of illicit activities.
- Banking sector failure to provide meaningful credit; small depositors incur large losses on FX withdrawals; medium-to-large deposits remain indefinitely locked.
- Accelerating emigration, particularly of skilled workers, undermining future growth prospects.
Recommended comprehensive reform package (priority policy actions)
- Medium-term fiscal strategy to restore debt sustainability and create space for social and development spending:
- Adopt a 2023 Budget that uses a unified market exchange rate for customs and tax purposes, adjusts specific taxes to inflation, and takes first steps to restore public administration.
- Budget to provide funding for essential social spending and initiate public sector reforms to improve efficiency over time.
- Subsequent revenue mobilization reforms focused on broadening the tax base, closing loopholes, and improving tax compliance through strengthened and modernized tax administration.
- Eliminate SOE losses and phase out transfers from the budget (particularly to the energy sector), improve public administration, and advance sustainable pension system reforms.
- Pursue gradual fiscal consolidation complementary to debt restructuring that should aim to reduce public debt to a sustainable level over the medium term.
- Credible restructuring of the financial system to restore viability and support recovery:
- Acknowledge and address upfront the large losses incurred by the central bank and commercial banks.
- Respect the hierarchy of claims and protect small depositors while limiting recourse to the public sector given its unsustainable debt position.
- Restructure and recapitalize viable banks under a timebound plan; unviable banks should exit the market.
- Amend the Banking Secrecy Law to address outstanding critical weaknesses and ensure relevant agencies have access to data on individuals’ transactions and deposits at the client level.
- Modernize the legal and institutional framework of the central bank and other banking authorities to strengthen governance and accountability.
- Publish the special audit of the central bank to increase transparency.
- Unification of exchange rates and tightening of monetary policy:
- Unify exchange rates to remove distortions, eliminate rent-seeking, reduce pressures on FX reserves, and pave the way for a market-determined exchange rate.
- Accompany unification with temporary capital controls to help guard limited FX resources and ensure an equitable solution for depositors.
- Implement tight monetary policy using all available tools; central bank financing to the government should be strictly prohibited.
- Foreign exchange interventions should be very limited and only to address disorderly market conditions.
- Ambitious structural reforms to create an enabling environment for stronger growth:
- Strengthen the public finance management (PFM) framework to ensure oversight of public finances, enhance fiscal discipline, and improve budget transparency:
- Introduce a modern PFM law covering internal and external controls, a medium-term fiscal framework, restrictions on treasury advances, and a fully integrated treasury single account.
- Reform state-owned enterprises (SOEs) to ensure good governance, transparency, financial and operational viability, and containment of fiscal risks:
- Prepare a comprehensive inventory of SOEs and complete and publish financial audits of the largest SOEs as first steps.
- Develop an ownership strategy establishing strategic purposes, oversight, and management principles for SOEs.
- Swiftly implement sector reforms already approved by the cabinet in March 2022 to address long-standing issues in the electricity sector.
- Enhance governance, anti-corruption, and AML/CFT frameworks to regain social trust and promote inclusive growth:
- Use the ongoing governance diagnostic as a roadmap, including measures to enhance the independence and integrity of the judiciary and improve accountability across the public sector.
- Implement the approved procurement law promptly, starting with full functionality of the Procurement Authority and the e-procurement platform.
International support and IMF engagement
- The IMF remains committed to supporting Lebanon with policy advice and technical assistance and will continue close engagement with the authorities.
- Collaboration and support from multilateral and bilateral partners are critical for successful implementation of reforms; such support will hinge on Lebanon’s commitment and steadfast implementation of a comprehensive and ambitious reform program.
- The authorities committed to work with the IMF and other international partners for policy implementation, including under an IMF-supported program.
Source: Lebanon: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission (March 23, 2023).