Aid, Exports, and Growth: A Time-Series Perspective on the Dutch Disease Hypothesis
IMF Working Papers, March 20, 2013
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Aid, Exports, and Growth: A Time-Series Perspective on the Dutch Disease Hypothesis
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Joong S Kang, Alessandro Prati, Alessandro Rebucci
- Published: March 20, 2013
- Series: IMF Working Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9781484320112.001
Summary
- Authors: Joong S Kang, Alessandro Prati, Alessandro Rebucci
- Date: March 20, 2013
- Core objective: Study the dynamic response of exports, imports, and per capita GDP growth to a “global” aid shock using a heterogeneous panel VAR model identified through factor analysis.
- Main high-level result: A global aid shock can affect exports, imports, and growth either positively or negatively, producing a mixed relation between aid and growth that aligns with ambiguous findings in existing literature.
- Key interpretation: For most countries in the sample, when aid reduces exports and imports, it also reduces growth; and, when aid increases exports and imports, it also increases growth. This evidence is consistent with a Dutch Disease (DD) hypothesis but indicates that aid-receiving countries are not inevitably subject to DD.
Methods
- Empirical approach: Heterogeneous panel VAR model.
- Identification strategy: Identified through factor analysis.
- Variables analyzed: Exports, imports, per capita GDP growth, and a “global” aid shock.
Findings and Evidence
- Directional effects: A global aid shock can produce either positive or negative responses in exports, imports, and per capita GDP growth.
- Cross-country heterogeneity: The aid–growth relation is mixed across countries in the sample.
- Co-movement pattern: For most sample countries, reductions (increases) in exports and imports associated with aid correspond to reductions (increases) in growth.
- Theoretical implication: Results are consistent with the DD hypothesis while allowing for cases where aid does not induce DD.
Policy-relevant implications
- Heterogeneity matters: Policy assessments of aid should account for country-specific responses in trade and growth rather than assume uniform Dutch Disease effects.
- Monitoring trade dynamics: Since aid can influence exports and imports in either direction with corresponding growth effects, policymakers should monitor export and import responses to aid inflows to assess growth implications.
- Conditional concerns: The presence of DD effects in many but not all countries suggests targeted policies can mitigate adverse trade and growth outcomes when aid risks reducing tradable-sector performance.