Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Discusses Recent Experiences in Managing Capital Inflows
IMF News, April 5, 2011
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Discusses Recent Experiences in Managing Capital Inflows
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: April 5, 2011
Background
- Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 11/42: On March 21, 2011 the Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) discussed a staff paper “Recent Experiences in Managing Capital Inflows—Cross-Cutting Themes and Possible Policy Framework” and related documents — Supplement and Statement by the Managing Director.
- Context and drivers of inflows:
- Capital flows have returned with the ebbing of the global financial crisis, bringing investment and growth benefits to recipient countries, but also important macroeconomic and financial stability challenges.
- Improved fundamentals and growth prospects in emerging markets and loose monetary policy in advanced economies are among the main pull and push factors behind the recent wave of inflows to emerging markets.
- Scope of staff work:
- The staff paper reviews the experience of selected countries in dealing with capital inflows and suggests a possible framework for Fund policy advice on the spectrum of measures available to policymakers to manage inflows, including macroeconomic policies, prudential measures, and capital controls.
- The suggested framework is intended to inform policy discussions with all Fund members with open capital accounts and is part of a broader and still ongoing work agenda on capital flows covering the entire Fund membership.
- The broader agenda includes additional analysis on the drivers of global capital flows, such as global liquidity and accommodative monetary policy in advanced economies, policy advice for countries that seek to liberalize their capital accounts and that originate capital flows, and will be informed by the findings of the upcoming “spillover reports,” which will assess outward policy spillovers from the five largest systemic economies (China, Euro Area, Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United States).
Key findings and analysis
- Benefits and risks of inflows:
- Capital inflows are generally beneficial for recipient countries, promoting investment and growth.
- A sudden surge in inflows can pose challenges, including currency appreciation pressures, overheating, the buildup of financial fragilities, and the risk of a sudden reversal of inflows.
- Country experiences and heterogeneity:
- Policy responses to the recent inflow surge have varied across countries.
- Countries have generally complemented macroeconomic policy with other measures to manage inflows, although there are wide differences in the nature, extent, and effectiveness of these measures.
- Analytical gaps noted by Directors:
- Most Directors noted that the cross-country analysis should have included a broader spectrum of countries and a more comprehensive analysis of the supply-side factors in driving inflows.
Policy framework and recommended instruments
- Role of instruments:
- The staff paper proposes a spectrum of measures—macroeconomic policies, prudential measures, and capital controls—to manage capital inflows.
- Capital flow management measures (CFMs), encompassing a number of prudential, administrative and tax measures designed to influence inflows, are squarely within the toolkit and could be used to address macroeconomic and financial risks related to inflows.
- Conditions for employing CFMs (as noted by most Directors):
- CFMs should be employed when appropriate macroeconomic conditions are in place, namely:
- if the exchange rate is not undervalued,
- reserves are in excess of adequate prudential levels,
- the cyclical position of the economy precludes monetary easing, and
- there is no scope to tighten fiscal policy.
- CFMs should not be used as a substitute for necessary macroeconomic policy adjustment.
- Emphasis on structural and macroeconomic measures:
- Emphasis should be placed on structural measures to increase the capacity of the economy to absorb capital inflows and strengthen the resilience of the domestic financial system.
- When confronted with surging inflows, macroeconomic policies are appropriate tools—namely, rebalancing the monetary and fiscal policy mix consistent with inflation objectives, allowing the currency to strengthen if it is undervalued, and building foreign exchange reserves if these are not more than adequate from a precautionary perspective.
- Some Directors observed difficulties in the degree of judgment required in determining appropriateness of macroeconomic policies, currency undervaluation, or reserve adequacy.
Executive Board views, endorsements, and disagreements
- Broad endorsement and reservations:
- A majority of the Board noted their broad endorsement of the framework set forth in Box 1 and paragraphs 42−58 of the paper, which constitutes a first-round articulation of the Fund’s institutional views on responses to manage capital inflows.
- This framework would be intended to inform policy discussions with all member countries facing large capital inflows and could evolve over time based on experience gained.
- A number of Directors broadly supported Board consideration at a later stage on incorporating the framework into Fund surveillance.
- Minority concerns:
- A few Directors thought that establishing a framework for managing inflows was premature because analytical consensus does not yet exist and because any framework should also encompass policy responses to push (supply side) factors that lead to capital inflows.
- A significant minority of the Board was concerned that such a framework would restrict the range of policy responses for countries facing large capital inflows and were opposed to incorporating the framework into Fund surveillance, emphasizing that policymakers need flexibility and discretion.
- Flexibility and simultaneous use of tools:
- Many Directors emphasized the need for flexibility in the proposed framework, warning against an overly sequential approach.
- A number of Directors noted that CFMs may need to be used simultaneously with macroeconomic measures.
- Spillover and negative externalities:
- A number of Directors noted that countries should take due account of any negative spillovers of CFMs, although a few Directors noted that evidence on such spillovers is yet to be established.
- Evenhandedness and country-specificity:
- Directors emphasized that policy advice on managing inflows should be evenhanded and give due regard to country-specific circumstances and the external setting.
Next steps and related work program
- Directors welcomed staff work plans in related areas that will enhance the comprehensiveness of policy discussions regarding capital flows.
- Planned additional analysis includes:
- analysis of policies in source countries that give rise to capital flows, and
- analysis of capital account liberalization.
Public Information Notice No. 11/42 — Executive Board discussion on “Recent Experiences in Managing Capital Inflows—Cross-Cutting Themes and Possible Policy Framework” (March 21, 2011).