International Role of the Euro
IMF News, September 19, 2019
Source details
- Canonical URL
- International Role of the Euro
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: September 19, 2019
Introduction
- Speech delivered in Brussels, September 19, 2019.
- Speaker addresses what can be done to strengthen the euro’s role as a reserve currency on the euro’s 20th anniversary.
- Motivation for strengthening the euro includes perceived US “exorbitant privilege” and desire to reduce vulnerabilities from dollar dominance.
- Reference to Bank of England Governor Mark Carney’s view that a multi-polar global economy requires diversification of international reserve currencies.
What makes a good international reserve currency and how the euro compares
- Key features from economic research for a reserve currency:
- Large transaction area:
- The eurozone accounted for 16 percent of global GDP in 2018, making it the second largest single currency zone in the world in terms of output.
- Good institutions:
- Euro area countries rank in the top 20 percent of all countries on the rule of law (World Governance Indicators, with a few exceptions).
- The ECB has shown strong commitment to its inflation objective and independence.
- Deep, liquid, and open financial markets:
- In 2018, euro area bond and equity markets were worth about 20 trillion dollars compared to over 50 trillion dollars in the US.
- Less than 30 percent of euro area nonfinancial corporations’ financing comes from tradable debt and listed equity versus about 70 percent for US firms.
- Euro area financial markets are more fragmented than in the US; there is no single sovereign market comparable to US Treasuries.
- Backing of a strong central state:
- The euro area is an economic and monetary union but not a political union; absence of a strong central state is a limiting feature for the euro challenging the dollar.
- Historical context:
- The euro inherited reserve currency status in large measure from the deutsche mark and expanded on it.
- International use of the euro rose in its first decade but declined sharply during the euro area debt crisis.
- Structural and policy weaknesses that undermined credibility during crises:
- National policies in some member states inconsistent with monetary union membership.
- High public debt levels in several countries with insufficient debt-reduction efforts.
- Low productivity and competitiveness gaps and insufficient structural reforms in some countries.
- Large and persistent external and fiscal surpluses in some countries with insufficient boost to domestic investment and demand.
Prospects for improving the euro area functioning and increasing the euro’s international role
- Three critical issues identified:
1. Balance between network effects of a single currency and desire for diversification of reserve currencies.
- Network effects are strong; history shows multiple major international currencies can co-exist.
- Increasing invoicing of international trade in euros is a policy objective but outcomes depend on individual actors and network strength.
- Euro pricing of truly global commodities (e.g., oil) faces strong efficiency advantages for a single currency—limits prospects of displacing the dollar in such markets.
2. Depth and liquidity of euro area financial markets:
- Developing deeper and more liquid euro-denominated markets is promising for strengthening the euro’s role.
- Key unfinished elements of banking union:
- A common deposit insurance scheme for banks is the biggest missing element.
- Further strengthening of bank resolution and supervision frameworks is needed.
- Reduce fragmentation of rules and regulations along national lines.
- Capital Market Union (CMU):
- Growing political sense that capital market integration could be an easier path to EMU deepening than other reforms.
- CMU and banking union completion are long-term projects, but there is encouraging political willingness to reinvigorate efforts.
- Realistic caveat: euro area financial markets will never be as integrated as in the US due to political obstacles (e.g., harmonization of bankruptcy procedures) and structural differences (prevalence of SMEs and relationship banking in Europe).
3. How well the euro area functions for its members (the main limitation):
- Need to overhaul fiscal rules and create a central fiscal capacity to provide insurance against country-specific risks.
- Member states must adopt policies consistent with monetary union membership:
- Reduce fiscal vulnerabilities where high.
- Implement structural reforms to address low productivity growth and competitiveness gaps.
- Countries with sizable external surpluses should invest more domestically and support faster wage growth to aid intra-area rebalancing.
- Without stronger policy coherence at the national level and completion of the euro area architecture, the euro will remain more vulnerable to shocks and unlikely to rival the dollar.
Safe assets and their role
- The euro area lacks a single safe asset comparable to US Treasuries.
- Increasing supply of euro-denominated safe assets would help the euro’s global role, but prospects are constrained:
- Calls for Germany and other AAA-rated countries to issue more debt face political resistance; fiscal objectives are difficult to align with supplying global safe assets.
- Debate centers on risk-sharing versus risk-reduction:
- Proposals to create a common euro area safe asset (jointly backed debt) raise moral hazard concerns.
- Counter-argument: poorer national policies caused downgrades; making lower-rated assets safer would require better national policies—more prudent fiscal policy and more ambitious structural reforms.
- A common safe asset is not a silver bullet; it cannot bypass fundamental challenges regarding risk-sharing versus risk-reduction.
Overall assessment and concluding policy implications
- Progress that would help strengthen the euro’s international role:
- Further advancement on banking union and capital market union could help strengthen the euro’s global role.
- Deeper, more liquid, and more integrated financial markets in the euro area are important and politically plausible to an extent.
- Fundamental constraints:
- The euro’s international role will remain limited until:
- Fundamental problems in national policies (fiscal discipline, structural reforms) are addressed.
- Shortcomings in the euro area’s architecture exposed since the global financial crisis are resolved.
- Final verdict:
- Enhancing the global role of the euro is a welcome by-product of broader reforms needed to make the euro work better for Europe; but there are no easy shortcuts to creating a stronger reserve-currency role for the euro.
International Monetary Fund