New Zealand: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Discussions
IMF News, March 12, 2021
Source details
- Canonical URL
- New Zealand: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Discussions
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: March 12, 2021
Pandemic response and economic recovery
- New Zealand’s management of the COVID-19 crisis suppressed infections and enabled a faster-than-expected economic recovery.
- Health measures cited as effective: strict layered quarantine requirements, testing, contact tracing, social distancing, and ongoing border closure.
- Policy support:
- Direct fiscal support measures of about 19.2 percent of GDP (through fiscal year 2024/25).
- Monetary policy measures: policy rate cut to 0.25 percent, Large-Scale Asset Purchase Program, Funding for Lending Program.
- Other support: Small Business Cashflow and Business Finance Guarantee schemes, wage subsidies, infrastructure investment, tax measures to support business cashflow and investment.
- Economic outcomes:
- Real GDP contracted sharply in early 2020 then recovered quickly, returning to above pre-COVID level by late 2020.
- Tourism and education exports lag due to closed border.
- Inflation at 1.4 percent in 2020Q4, below the RBNZ target-range mid-point.
- Hourly wages grew modestly in 2020Q4.
- Job losses concentrated in contact-intensive services, disproportionately affecting low-skilled workers, youth, women, and some ethnic groups.
Near-term outlook and risks
- Growth expectations:
- Activity expected to expand at a slower pace in coming quarters due to border closure and high uncertainty.
- Wage growth expected to remain modest.
- Inflation expected to durably reach 2 percent in 2023.
- Key downside risks:
- Renewed domestic outbreaks delaying border reopening (Auckland lockdown cited).
- COVID-19 impacts on trading partners and export commodity prices.
- Business insolvency increase with expiry of COVID-19 support.
- Upside scenario:
- Faster global containment could prompt quicker border reopening and faster recovery of tourism and international education.
- Housing and financial stability risks:
- Rapid rise in house prices raises affordability and financial vulnerability concerns.
- Risks from rising speculative demand, historically low interest rates, structural supply shortages, and banks’ concentrated exposure to residential mortgage lending.
- Potential triggers for correction: unsustainable house prices relative to income, tightening of credit standards, or sharp rise in mortgage rates.
Policy stance: fiscal and monetary
- Overall guidance:
- No additional stimulus needed at the current juncture, but fiscal and monetary support should not be withdrawn prematurely given uneven recovery and high uncertainty.
- Authorities should stand ready to deploy additional monetary and fiscal stimulus should downside risks materialize.
- Fiscal policy recommendations:
- Remain sufficiently accommodative in the near term, as envisaged by current policy plans, to ensure transition from public to private demand and limit scarring.
- Pace of fiscal normalization should be carefully calibrated to support employment and minimize bankruptcies of distressed but viable firms.
- Be prepared to deploy additional fiscal support, including public investment and fiscal lifelines such as liquidity and targeted income support measures, if recovery falters.
- Contingency measures to manage resurgence events are welcomed.
- Monetary policy recommendations:
- Continue to be data dependent and likely remain accommodative for an extended period.
- Avoid tightening until inflation and employment objectives are sustainably achieved.
- RBNZ has additional room for monetary easing, potentially including negative policy rates, if downside risks materialize.
- If recovery proves stronger-than-expected, consider gradual withdrawal of monetary stimulus.
- Address surging house prices primarily via fiscal, regulatory, and macroprudential measures; monetary policy may play a role if house prices threaten the inflation objective.
Labor market and social policies
- Shift from job retention (wage subsidies) to active labor market policies is appropriate.
- Expansion of training and Flexi-wage subsidies to facilitate reallocation of workers.
- Permanent increase in unemployment benefits from a relatively low level strengthens automatic stabilizers.
- Support for displaced workers and disadvantaged groups, and promotion of long-term human capital accumulation, recommended.
Financial sector resilience and macroprudential measures
- Monitoring needed for vulnerabilities as relief measures unwind and insolvencies rise.
- Banks remain adequately capitalized and liquid, but concentrated exposure to residential mortgages and elevated household debt increase risk.
- Strengthening supervisory and regulatory functions at the RBNZ is welcome; Phase Two Review of the RBNZ Act seen as an opportunity to ensure operational autonomy and macroprudential toolkit availability.
- Capital policy:
- Extension of implementation of the 2019 Capital Review, raising banks’ required capitalization starting in July 2022, mitigates premature tightening of lending conditions while committing to further increases over the medium term.
- Macroprudential actions:
- Reinstatement of loan-to-value ratio (LVR) restrictions in March and further tightening for investors from May 2021 welcomed.
- Additional tools under consideration: debt-to-income ratio limits, caps on investor interest-only loans, higher bank capital risk weights on mortgage lending.
Housing supply, demand, and structural reforms
- Long-term affordability depends on increasing supply:
- Free up land supply, improve planning and zoning, and foster infrastructure investments to enable fast-track housing developments.
- Support for local councils’ infrastructure funding and financing is helpful.
- Reform of the Resource Management Act expected to reduce land-use complexities restricting infrastructure and housing development.
- Increasing social housing stock remains important; Residential Development Response Fund plans to deliver 18,000 public houses and transitional housing space, undertake rental housing reforms, and provide assistance to low-income households.
- Near-term demand-side measures:
- Mitigate investor demand to moderate price pressures.
- Options include introduction of stamp duties or expansion of capital gains taxation, with differentiation between first home buyers and investors.
- Continue selective grant and loan assistance to first-time buyers.
Structural and growth-enhancing reforms
- Recommendations to foster durable, inclusive, and green growth:
- Expand research and development spending and product market reforms to accelerate productivity growth.
- Reform of the Overseas Investment Act to streamline foreign direct investment approvals, deepen connectivity; welcome government’s intention to use the new national interest test sparingly.
- Target infrastructure spending to reduce the infrastructure gap and re-orient investment towards low-emissions infrastructure and technology.
New Zealand: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Discussions — March 11, 2021