United Kingdom Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Mission
IMF News, December 14, 2021
Source details
- Canonical URL
- United Kingdom Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: December 14, 2021
Developments and Outlook
- Rapid vaccination campaign led to reopening during the summer of 2021; recovery faster than expected amid strong continued policy support.
- Output and employment have returned to close to pre-pandemic levels, backed by strong policy support for jobs and firms.
- Financial stability has been maintained; fiscal policy rotated toward end year to more targeted support, with public debt and deficits expected to stabilize.
- Structural and behavioral shifts from Covid-19 have:
- shifted demand from services to goods;
- made work more digital and social interaction more localized;
- restrained labor market participation.
- These shifts have strained supply chains, contributed to rising traded goods and energy prices, and tightened labor markets, putting pressure on inflation.
- Omicron led to reintroduction of some activity restrictions and accelerated booster rollout.
- Forecasts and medium-term outlook:
- growth of about 6.8 percent in 2021;
- growth of 5 percent in 2022, with a mild slowdown in 2022Q1 due to newly introduced restrictions, and supply bottlenecks still prevalent during 2022H1;
- inflation would peak at about 5½ percent in the spring of 2022, before gradually returning to target by early 2024 (helped by declining global energy prices, more robust supply chains, and tighter demand management policies);
- in the medium-term, growth would ease to about 1½ percent, with real GDP settling about 2–2½ percent below its pre-pandemic trend, held back by investment shortfalls in 2020–21 and a less-than-full recovery of labor force participation.
- Risks:
- Near term: risk of higher inflation.
- 2–3 years out: risk shifts to lower growth as policy interventions pull inflation back.
- External risks: rapid tightening of global financial conditions, global slowdown, or continued frictions in the UK-EU relationship.
- Major risk: new Covid-19 waves (e.g., Omicron) that could either extend demand-supply imbalances and inflationary pressures or, if more virulent, weigh on confidence and demand with disinflationary impact.
Near-Term Macroeconomic Management Priorities
- Monetary policy:
- Needs to withdraw the exceptional support provided during 2020–21.
- Policymakers must weigh risks given Covid-19/Omicron uncertainty: early action could slow an uncertain recovery; inaction could allow second-round inflation effects to proliferate.
- Initial steps would still leave policy accommodative; changes can signal to dampen inflation expectations.
- Policy should focus on the period 12 to 24 months out, when it has maximum impact.
- Fiscal policy:
- Should retain an important role responding to large macroeconomic shocks.
- If present outlook holds, authorities could bring forward some fiscal tightening from FY23–24 to FY22–23 to help contain demand in the short run and reduce drag on growth in outer years.
- To avoid re-opening the Spending Review, authorities could adjust spending profiles and/or broaden the tax base at the uppermost income quintile (to be later matched by more build back better spending).
- If a virulent Covid-19 wave requires widespread mandated closures, authorities should be ready to redeploy a subset of previous exceptional programs (such as a furlough scheme and targeted support to the most vulnerable households and small businesses), with attention to lessons on design (including tapering and timely sunset).
- Macroprudential/supervisory vigilance:
- Financial cycle appears slightly ahead of the economic one; risks may build fast as investors search for yield in a low real rate environment and mortgage market/house prices respond to demand-supply dynamics.
- The Financial Policy Committee’s decision to proactively and gradually reestablish the countercyclical capital buffer is welcome.
- Latest adjustments to structural mortgage recommendations may warrant some simplification; vigilance on housing market developments and systemic risk is necessary.
- Continue to analyze effectiveness of measures and detect leakages early; bank stress test design must capture housing market correction risks and related systemic contagion channels.
Managing Policies with Higher Macroeconomic and Macrofinancial Volatility
- Macro landscape likely to be more volatile due to sectoral shifts (post-pandemic, post-Brexit norms, energy transition) and possibly less potent endogenous stabilizers (net immigration and imports).
- Fiscal policy role:
- Automatic stabilizers are key; changes from the Spending Review will increase automatic stabilizers.
- Opportunities to expand automatic funding of active labor market policies for youth (e.g., Kickstart-like), while preserving discretion to adapt design.
- Note: a program like the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS) should not be part of the regular toolkit in the UK and is best reserved for very large, temporary, and non-structural shocks.
- Monetary policy trade-offs:
- Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee has tools and discretion to manage inflation back to target but may face difficult trade-offs amid extended shifts in relative wages and prices.
- Important to avoid inaction bias; careful communication needed to prepare markets for potentially more frequent policy moves.
- Non-bank finance resilience:
- FSAP (2021) found need to improve liquidity risk resilience of the broader non-bank financial sector to avoid disruptions to core markets.
- Major cross-border challenge; UK, foreign authorities, international standard setting bodies and the FSB should speedily augment data collection, monitoring, and self-insurance in NBFIs.
- Authorities should strengthen backstops to core market functioning by considering allowing appropriately regulated, large, interconnected NBFIs access to repo and/or Gilt purchase operations.
Anchoring Policies and Preserving Space through Strong Frameworks
- Fiscal rules:
- New fiscal rules have anchored fiscal policy well; addition of debt affordability and balance sheet considerations are important innovations.
- Rules reflect choices of the elected government, which increases accountability but may lead to more variation in design going forward.
- Parliament would benefit from more structured commentary on whether new calibrations meet higher order fiscal objectives; the Office for Budget Responsibility’s material could inform timely updates to Parliament.
- Monetary policy toolkit:
- Bank of England’s 2021 technical facilitation to implement a negative policy rate creates policy space.
- Opportunity to cement Bank Rate as key instrument by making the quantitative tightening (QT) strategy as predictable as possible.
- Recommendation: Monetary Policy Committee could put the QT program onto a pre-programmed course at the earliest opportunity and the Bank give guidance on the framework to manage the process back towards the steady state balance sheet (recognizing need to assess market conditions as demand for reserves may change over time).
- Financial stability framework:
- FSAP found UK’s framework resilient but with opportunities for enhancements.
- Financial soundness of UK banks and insurers has increased since the global financial crisis; system well placed to face near-term macrofinancial challenges.
- Structural transitions include growing market-based finance, Libor cessation, making finance green, greater cyber risk exposure, and rapid digital adoption—many cross-border in nature.
- FSAP suggested:
- continued enhancements to the perimeter of systemic risk monitoring and analysis;
- accelerated efforts to address data and information gaps (including internationally) and track exposures and risk management practices of complex cross-border financial firms;
- pushing ahead with pro-active approaches to tackle climate-related and cyber threat related financial risks.
Building Back Better
- Authorities’ growth plan:
- Staff welcomes pillars (infrastructure, skills, and innovation) and strategies (Levelling Up, Net Zero, and Global Britain).
- Spending Review commits significant funding for these pillars and objectives until 2025.
- Opportunities to further advance within proposed fiscal rules by raising revenues, e.g., broadening the tax base for the upper end of the income distribution.
- Infrastructure investment:
- Authorities have substantially increased investment spending; concerns remain about value-for-money and deliverability.
- UK has one of the strongest public investment management frameworks worldwide; options exist to address potential bottlenecks (coordination between levels of government, project appraisal methodologies).
- Improved investment management could motivate a less restrictive budgetary investment cap.
- Skills and labor market:
- Many new initiatives (Lifetime Skills Guarantee, Kickstart and Restart programs, Skills bootcamps); some will be more effective and should be prioritized.
- Staff modeling suggests a period of creative destruction; facilitating sectoral labor shifts is important.
- Higher funding for skills-building policies should be a priority.
- Net Zero Strategy:
- Major achievement; private sector must drive progress, emphasizing carbon pricing and regulation.
- Opportunities to be more ambitious, including more rapidly extending the UK’s ETS and legally clarifying the phase in of regulations.
- Greater ambition requires more upfront compensation for vulnerable groups (including grants for homes requiring significant retrofits) and tailoring skills programs to retrain fossil-fuel industry workers.
- Post-Brexit frameworks:
- Major strides in post-Brexit trade and financial sector frameworks.
- Remaining issues of contention between the UK and EU; staff urges mutually beneficial outcomes.
- As UK reviews its post-Brexit financial regulatory framework, it will be important to preserve primacy of financial stability objectives and safeguard management of domestic and cross-border macroeconomic and financial sector systemic risks.
United Kingdom Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Article IV Mission — December 14, 2021