Czech Republic: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission
IMF News, November 22, 2023
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Czech Republic: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: November 22, 2023
Overview
- Growth slowed considerably following Russia’s war in Ukraine due to disruptions in global value chains, significant increases in energy and other commodity prices, an erosion in real wages, and a necessary tightening in monetary policy.
- Growth is expected to pick up in 2024—led by consumption and fixed investment, as inflation fades and real income starts rising again, supported by net exports.
- GDP is unlikely to reach the levels that would have been given by its pre-pandemic trend by 2028.
- Inflation, having peaked in 2022, is projected to meet the CNB’s target by early 2025.
- Risks are tilted to the downside for activity and to the upside for inflation.
Key Policy Recommendations
- Monetary policy
- Keep the policy stance tight for some time to ensure inflation returns to target in a timely manner and to reduce the risk of an upward shift in inflation expectations.
- High uncertainty calls for a flexible, data-driven, meeting-by-meeting approach to policy setting.
- Fiscal policy
- Allow automatic stabilizers to function fully given the uncertain outlook.
- Preserve and enhance policy space despite a low debt-to-GDP ratio to address future shocks, support economic transformation, and help ensure long-term debt sustainability.
- Macrofinancial policies
- Current levels of the countercyclical capital buffer, loan-to-value and debt-to-income ratios seem appropriate.
- Reactivate the debt-service-to-income ratio (DSTI) to help manage potential systemic risks; recalibrate and improve its design, including by legislative changes, rather than deactivation/reactivation.
- Closely monitor risks from an increasing share of euro-denominated bank loans.
- Structural policies
- Aid labor and capital reallocation, boost digitalization and productivity, and accelerate the green transformation to address structural changes including population aging and the global shift away from fossil-fuel based power.
Outlook and Risks
- Activity and projections
- 2023 real GDP growth is estimated to have declined to -0.4 percent, mainly reflecting a decline in household consumption amid a significant fall in real wages, deteriorating consumer sentiment, and heightened uncertainty.
- Growth is projected to increase to about 1.2 percent in 2024, mainly driven by a recovery of consumption and fixed investment as inflation declines and real wages recover.
- Aggregate investment will be dampened by subdued public investment, mainly due to a gradual phase in of the new cycle of the EU investment and structural funds (2021-2027).
- Labor market: unemployment rate projected to decrease modestly to about 2.6 percent in 2024.
- Wage growth is projected to decline gradually as real wages catch up towards labor productivity.
- Staff projects recovery in real wages and real unit labor costs to be matched by a compression in profit shares back to their pre-energy-shock levels, allowing the disinflation process to continue.
- Inflation
- Projected to meet the CNB’s target by early 2025.
- Ongoing disinflation reflects diminishing commodity price shocks and a substantial decrease in domestic demand pressures; falling core inflation primarily reflects the dampening effect of the tight monetary policy stance.
- Downward trend in headline inflation paused in 2023Q4 due to a statistical base effect from last year’s drop in electricity prices caused by the government’s energy savings tariff; decline projected to resume once base effect subsides.
- Downside risks to growth
- Spillovers from a weaker global outlook, renewed surge in global energy prices, new supply chain disruptions, increased geopolitical tensions, broader geo-economic fragmentation.
- Heightened global financial volatility could negatively impact pricing and availability of financing.
- Low probability but possible disorderly house price correction could impair banks’ and households’ balance sheets, tightening financial conditions and reducing aggregate demand.
- Upside risks to inflation
- Inflation expectations remaining above target and becoming untethered, a tight labor market, currently elevated but declining household saving rate.
- Strong wage growth and failure of profit margins to compress rapidly could lead to stronger repricing of goods and services.
- New global energy or commodity price shocks or a reversal of the expected decrease in administered prices.
- Abrupt return of household saving rate to near long-term average levels could boost consumption and heighten demand-driven inflationary pressures.
- Depreciation pressure on the koruna from a falling policy rate differential vis-a-vis major central banks or geopolitical shifts could add to inflationary pressures.
- Conversely, a slower recovery or an unexpected significant fall in global demand could accelerate convergence of inflation to target.
Monetary Policy
- Recommendation: maintain a tight monetary policy stance until there is firm evidence that inflation is on course to converge to target.
- Context and guidance:
- The policy rate has remained unchanged since June 2022.
- Recent decreases in inflation and its expectations have raised the ex-ante real policy interest rate and tightened the monetary policy stance.
- Staff advises keeping the nominal policy rate broadly unchanged through early 2024 to consolidate disinflation and provide insurance against de-anchoring of inflation expectations.
- Thereafter, the nominal policy interest rate could be lowered cautiously and gradually, with pace accelerated if inflation expectations align faster to the target.
- Given high uncertainty around commodity prices, wages, profits, and inflation, adopt a data-driven, meeting-by-meeting approach.
Fiscal Policy
- Short-term stance
- 2024 fiscal plans appropriately emphasize consolidation, but fiscal policy should remain flexible given the uncertain outlook.
- In cyclically adjusted terms, staff projects the fiscal deficit to contract by 1.3 percent of potential GDP.
- Contractionary stance supports disinflation efforts, with the output gap set to nearly close in 2024.
- Allow automatic stabilizers to operate given growth uncertainty.
- Medium-term framework and targets
- Fiscal policy guided by Czechia’s fiscal responsibility act (FRA), which sets a minimum fiscal consolidation path to deliver a sustainable debt-to-GDP ratio and a low prudent fiscal balance.
- Staff’s baseline envisages a debt-to-GDP ratio of 42.5 percent and a structural balance of -0.8 percent of potential GDP by 2028, consistent with the MTO—a structural balance of -0.75 percent of GDP.
- Czechia is at a low overall risk of sovereign stress; reaching the MTO by 2028 will contribute to medium-term debt sustainability.
- The November 2023 fiscal outlook identifies measures through 2025 but reaching the MTO would require identifying additional measures.
- Long-term pressures and recommendations
- Spending pressures will increase to facilitate economic transformation toward a green digital economy and address population aging.
- Pension funding gap in the long-term implies the actuarial deficit calls for higher general government structural balances than the currently targeted MTO.
- An additional buffer is warranted to protect against future shocks and fiscal risks.
- Although EU funds will cover part of forthcoming spending pressures, additional fiscal measures are required:
- Ensure that the Personal Income Tax (PIT) and real estate related taxes deliver pre-pandemic tax revenue as a percentage of GDP; this would yield above 1.5 percent of GDP.
- Further advance pension reform, complementing recent regulatory reforms, including linking retirement age to life expectancy.
- Use growth-friendly tax measures, reprioritization of spending, and improved spending efficiency.
Macroprudential and Financial Sector Policies
- Macroprudential stance
- Partial release of the Countercyclical Capital Buffer (CCyB) was justified based on financial cycle estimates.
- Maintain Loan-to-Value (LTV) and Debt-to-Income (DTI) ratios at current levels.
- Reconsider deactivation of the Debt-Service-to-Income (DSTI) ratio; reinstate and recalibrate its design, including legislative changes.
- Monitor increasing euroization of corporate loans; incorporate these risks into financial stability analysis and capital requirements for banks’ FX positions.
- Banking sector assessment and vulnerabilities
- Banking sector is broadly resilient: well-capitalized, liquid, and profitable compared to European peers.
- Improvements in supervisory risk measurement for sectoral/individual exposures welcomed; further progress important.
- Pockets of vulnerability remain and require close monitoring:
- Risks related to increasing euroization of corporate loans, credit, exchange rate, and counterparty risks including derivatives.
- Since the pandemic, the banking sector’s direct risk exposure to the Treasury increased but remains contained; exposures need monitoring.
- Real estate exposure risks have diminished substantially but require continued monitoring for loan quality over the cycle and possible nonperforming loans.
Structural Policies
- Green transformation
- Government decarbonization strategy goals: phase out coal by 2033, increase shares of renewables and nuclear energy, and bolster energy efficiency to meet European climate and energy targets by 2030.
- Investment needs by 2050 estimated at about CZK 3.5 trillion, of which about CZK 1-1.2 trillion are identified from public support including EU funds.
- ETS1 and ETS2 (starting in 2027) will together cover most sources of emissions, tilting relative prices toward greener energy and encouraging efficiency.
- Recommendations to encourage private investment: regulatory guidance (banning registration of new fossil-fuel vehicles within the next decade, building energy efficiency requirements), feebates in agriculture, targeted subsidies for R&D, faster depreciation for machinery/equipment switching to clean fuels.
- Capital reallocation and business environment
- Streamline regulations related to business establishment and insolvency to promote corporate restructuring and improve capital reallocation.
- Simplify construction permitting and improve SMEs’ access to alternative funding, particularly venture capital and equity financing.
- Labor reallocation and skills
- Active labor market policies (ALMPs), training, and lifelong learning are crucial to support workers’ transition to growing sectors.
- Support for KOMPAS (Labor Market Prediction Project), Database of Retraining and Further Education Courses, and education system reforms.
- Recommendations to improve labor force participation and alleviate shortages:
- Step up policies for disadvantaged groups; welcome Job Integration Program (effective 2024).
- Improve vocational training and technical/digital education.
- Continue integrating women with young children via childcare provision, flexible parental allowances, and enhanced job search opportunities.
- Expand flexible and part-time work arrangements.
- Continue integrating refugees and facilitating migrant inflows with language training, childcare, job search support, and “pathways to work” for high-school immigrant children; continue developing an immigration point-based system.
- Technological innovation
- Incentives for R&D and targeted support to emerging and innovative firms to boost productivity and create high value-added sectors.
- Implement the Innovation Strategy and National Development Plan to foster technical and digital competencies, particularly in Knowledge Intensive Sectors.
- Accelerate Recovery and Resilience Facility reforms: provide digital equipment to schools, revise IT curriculum, expand life-long learning in digital technologies, and implement new digital governance structure.
Source: Czech Republic: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission