Malta: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission
IMF News, November 23, 2023
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Malta: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: November 23, 2023
Overview
- Malta has marked an impressive recovery from the pandemic and demonstrated substantial resilience to shocks resulting from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
- With weaker external demand and waning post-pandemic pent-up demand, growth is normalizing but is still expected to be among the highest in Europe.
- Key policy priorities identified by staff:
- Initiate a front-loaded fiscal tightening to rebuild fiscal buffers at a faster pace and help contain demand pressures.
- Prepare an exit strategy from the current generous energy subsidy policy and gradually implement it, with a view to containing fiscal costs and risks and enhancing incentives for energy conservation and transition, while protecting vulnerable populations.
- Maintain vigilance in monitoring financial sector risks, particularly in the areas of borrower creditworthiness, cyber security, and money laundering/terrorist financing.
- Boost structural reform efforts in innovation, digitalization, labor markets, education, and green transformation to achieve high, socially- and environmentally-sustainable, and inclusive growth.
Growth, Labor Markets, and Inflation
- Findings:
- Output growth has rebounded sharply since the reopening of the economy in 2021.
- Recovery aided by fiscal support, increased labor participation, large inflows of foreign workers, and limited passthrough from monetary policy interest rates to domestic retail lending rates.
- Staff expect real GDP to moderate but continue to expand by around 4 percent in 2023 and 3½ percent in 2024.
- Labor markets remain tight; the unemployment rate remains at historically low levels.
- Both headline and core inflation peaked a year ago and have since decelerated, but staff expect elevated inflation to remain persistent and above the 2 percent target until late 2025, in part reflecting tight labor markets and sustained demand pressure.
Risks to the Outlook
- Downside risks:
- Spillovers from a possible escalation of Russia’s war in Ukraine or of the Israel-Gaza conflict, with implications for global commodity prices.
- A deeper-than-expected economic downturn in Europe.
- Domestic risks: higher and more persistent wage and inflationary pressures; money laundering/terrorist financing risks; uncertainties around the effects of the EU’s Minimum Tax Directive (Pillar II).
- Upside scenario:
- Lower-than-expected commodity prices would help decelerate inflation, ease fiscal pressures, and boost growth.
Fiscal Policy, Deficits, and Public Debt
- Key figures and projections:
- 2023 overall deficit: 5 percent of GDP.
- 2024 Budget projects overall deficit: 4.5 percent of GDP.
- Energy subsidies will remain large at 1¾ percent of GDP, accounting for about 40 percent of the overall deficit.
- Structural balance: deficit of 4.3 percent of GDP in 2024 (compared to a surplus before the pandemic).
- Planned target: gradually reduce overall deficit to 3 percent of GDP by 2027 (assumes sustained strong growth and lower energy prices).
- General government debt trajectory: from 52 percent of GDP in 2022 to 57 percent in 2026, compared with 40 percent in 2019.
- Staff recommendation:
- Undertake a more sizable and front-loaded fiscal adjustment, on the order of additional 1½ percentage points of GDP over 2024-2025, to build larger fiscal buffers and contain demand pressure.
Energy Subsidies and Exit Strategy
- Assessment:
- The ongoing energy price shock can no longer be viewed as temporary; suppressing the price signal does not incentivize energy conservation or green transition.
- Large subsidies limit fiscal space for reallocations to productivity-enhancing reforms while consolidating the fiscal position.
- Recommended approach:
- Prepare an exit from the fixed price policy to contain fiscal costs and strengthen market price mechanisms, while protecting low-income and, to a lesser extent, middle-income households.
- Implement the strategy predictably and gradually, beginning with adjusting fuel prices to better reflect their import costs and making the electricity tariff structure more progressive.
- Note: A gradual move may ease pressures on consumers but would delay benefits of exit and leave public finances vulnerable to further energy price increases.
Revenues, Spending, and Tax Reform
- Revenue-side:
- Staff welcome a recently-launched comprehensive program to modernize the Commissioner for Revenue to improve efficiency and effectiveness of tax collection.
- Spending-side priorities:
- Review to identify scope for rationalizing recurrent spending and reallocating resources to boost productivity.
- Improve efficiency of public investment (including green).
- Strengthen public procurement by streamlining vetting, accelerating digitalization, and implementing a risk-based approach.
- Corporate income tax (CIT) and personal income tax (PIT):
- CIT reform is increasingly urgent in light of the EU’s Directive on OECD Pillar II.
- Authorities should develop a well-structured roadmap for phased implementation of CIT reform, including PIT reform given their interaction.
- The roadmap should be developed in consultation with stakeholders and announced by late 2024.
Financial Stability and AML/CFT
- Financial system soundness:
- Malta’s financial system remains sound and resilient; banks maintain ample capital and liquidity buffers.
- Authorities should ensure banks assess the effects of inflation and financial conditions on vulnerable and leveraged borrowers and update provisions for credit risks.
- Monitor price developments in the residential and commercial real estate sectors.
- Limited passthrough from monetary policy to retail lending and deposit rates; differential effects by bank size and business model warrant close monitoring.
- Increased allocation of resources towards cyber security is encouraged.
- Macroprudential measures:
- Authorities introduced a sectoral systemic capital buffer targeting residential mortgage exposures: initially set at 1 percent from end-September 2023 and increasing to 1.5 percent from end-March 2024.
- Continue to review the effectiveness and appropriateness of borrower-based measures, including loan-to-value, debt-service-to-income, and maturity limits.
- AML/CFT reforms:
- Resources for AML/CFT supervisors and regulators have been significantly boosted; collaboration mechanisms enhanced.
- Training programs for the private sector and a risk-based approach are being enhanced.
- Following a 2022 EU Court of Justice ruling, Malta suspended public access to the beneficial ownership (BO) registry; implications for AML/CFT robustness should be assessed and risk mitigation measures developed if warranted.
- Malta’s updated AML/CFT National Risk Assessment should be published by the end of this year as planned.
Structural Reforms, Productivity, and Green Transition
- Productivity and reform priorities:
- Boost research and innovation, address skill gaps, and tackle low take-up rate of adult learning for the low-skilled.
- Monitor education outcomes for students with non-EU backgrounds.
- Continue efforts to strengthen anti-corruption framework to ensure investor confidence.
- Green transition:
- Accelerate decarbonization and investments in renewables to strengthen resilience to energy shocks and competitiveness.
- Make steady progress implementing the 2021 Low Carbon Development Strategy.
- Allow greater passthrough of market energy prices to consumers to enhance incentives for energy saving and efficiency.
- Complete the climate vulnerability risk assessment and update the climate change adaption plan.
- Capacity constraints and economic strategy:
- Refocus the economic development strategy to analyze: (i) labor force and skills gaps; (ii) immigration policies to ensure the right supply of skills; (iii) needs in physical and social infrastructure, including roads, housing, education, and health services.
- Update the Strategic Plan for Environment and Development 2015 expeditiously to reflect latest demographic projections and align sectoral policies (e.g., tourism).
Monitoring Inequality and Social Protection
- The 2024 Budget introduced additional support for vulnerable groups, including pensioners.
- Given the risk of persistently high costs of living, authorities should continue to monitor impacts of inflation and other economic developments on inequality and evaluate the adequacy of the current tax and benefit system.
Staff Concluding Statement: Malta: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2023 Article IV Mission