Lebanon: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2018 Article IV Mission
IMF News, February 12, 2018
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Lebanon: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2018 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: February 12, 2018
Key messages
- Reform agenda needs to focus on three areas:
- Fiscal policy immediately anchored in a consolidation plan that stabilizes debt as a share of GDP and then places it on a clear downward path.
- Contain financial stability risks, including incentivizing banks to gradually strengthen their buffers and taking further actions to strengthen credit quality.
- Promote sustainable growth and improve equity and competitiveness by reforming the electricity sector and enhancing and making effective the anti‑corruption regulatory framework.
Context and immediate challenges
- Political and confidence environment:
- Lebanon emerged from the political crisis of November 2017, but vulnerabilities are higher.
- Interest rates on new local-currency bank deposits are 2–3 percentage points higher than before the crisis.
- Capital Investment Program (CIP) and refugee context:
- Lebanon hosts around 1 million registered Syrian refugees (equivalent to about a quarter of the population).
- Authorities plan to raise up to $16 billion (32 percent of current GDP) over the next decade via the World Bank’s Concessional Financing Facility, public-private partnerships, and other facilities.
- A conference in Paris to support investment in Lebanon is tentatively scheduled for April 2018.
- Macroeconomic fragility:
- Public debt is estimated above 150 percent of GDP at end-2017.
- The current account deficit persists at more than 20 percent of GDP.
- Budget deficit expected above 10 percent over the forecast horizon without adjustment.
Economic backdrop — growth, fiscal, and external positions
- Growth and inflation:
- Growth estimated at about 1–1.5 percent for 2017 and 2018.
- Inflation in 2017 reached 5 percent.
- Real estate prices declined by over 10 percent over 2017 (BdL data).
- Fiscal position:
- Overall budget deficit in 2017 is expected at 7.3 percent of GDP, with a primary balance of 2.4 percent.
- Parliament approved an across-the-board increase in the salary scale and pensions in July 2017.
- Subsidies to Electricité du Liban (EdL) are increasing, in part due to rising oil prices.
- External sector and exchange rate:
- Real effective exchange rate (REER) strengthened in 2017 by 2.8 percent.
- Current account deficit projected to have remained above 20 percent in 2017.
- Goods exports as a share of GDP continue to decline while imports remain strong.
- Deposit flows and monetary operations:
- Private sector deposit growth was 3.8 percent in 2017—below average growth in previous years.
- BdL introduced operations since summer 2016 offering incentives to banks to invest in BdL’s dollar-denominated term deposits, accelerating bank exposure to BdL.
- In December 2017 BdL introduced a new operation increasing the interest rate on existing BdL long‑term instruments held by banks by 2–3 percentage points.
- Sovereign market signals:
- Moody’s downgraded Lebanon from B2 to B3 in August 2017; Fitch and S&P maintained ratings at B-/B3 equivalent.
- During the November 2017 political crisis, Lebanese Eurobond spreads spiked by 200-300 bps but returned to pre-crisis levels by January 2018.
Outlook and scenarios
- Baseline projections:
- Growth will gradually rise close to 3 percent as external demand picks up.
- Inflation expected to remain around its trend of 2.5 percent.
- Overall fiscal balances are expected to reach well above 10 percent of GDP and public debt close to 180 percent of GDP by 2023.
- Current account deficit will remain large.
- Reserve adequacy position projected to deteriorate over the medium term under baseline assumptions of no reforms or increase in interest rates.
- Upside and downside risks:
- Upside: Early resolution in Syria could lead to reconstruction-related gains, reestablishment of trade, and improved regional investor confidence—positive for incomes and growth but insufficient alone to restore debt sustainability without adjustment.
- Downside: Escalation of regional tensions, higher oil prices, or decelerating deposit inflows could worsen funding needs and put pressure on foreign exchange reserves.
Policy priorities — fiscal consolidation
- Urgent need to preserve confidence and take advantage of international support.
- Debt dynamics and required adjustment:
- Lebanon’s debt is unsustainable under the baseline scenario and projected to rise to just below 180 percent of GDP by 2023 under current policies.
- A combination of increases in revenues and cuts in current spending amounting to about 5 percent of GDP is needed over the medium term to stabilize public debt as a share of GDP and place it on a gradually declining path.
- Without exchange rate adjustment and/or significant structural reforms, large current account deficits will likely persist even after fiscal consolidation.
- Components of a front‑loaded fiscal consolidation plan:
- Increase VAT rates, while limiting exemptions and refunds and improving compliance.
- Reinstate gasoline excise and fuel taxes to levels that prevailed before 2012.
- Gradually eliminate the electricity subsidy.
- Contain personnel spending and undertake civil service reform to reduce expenditure rigidity.
- Strengthen the social safety net to protect the vulnerable while pursuing consolidation.
- Public investment:
- CIP could boost growth if projects are well selected but will increase public debt and possibly borrowing costs.
- Any scaling up of investment must be grounded in a comprehensive macroeconomic adjustment plan and be preceded by strengthened public investment management.
- Risks and fiscal costs from PPPs need to be contained; consider gradual scaling up and seek highly-concessional financing while avoiding domestic financing of public investment.
Policy priorities — monetary normalization and financial stability
- Assessment of BdL operations:
- BdL policies have preserved stability but created market distortions, created new reserve money, weakened BdL’s balance sheet, and exposed banks to significant sovereign exposure and maturity mismatches.
- Recommended normalization steps:
- BdL should rely on conventional interest rate policy instead of repeated financial operations.
- If deposit growth softens, BdL should maintain tight liquidity and raise interest rates to secure foreign exchange inflows rather than repeat financial operations.
- BdL should gradually withdraw from the T-Bill and Eurobond primary market and reduce reliance on quasi-fiscal schemes.
- Banking system resilience:
- Align sovereign risk weights with the Basel Accord.
- Banks should engage in forward-looking capital planning linked to multi-factor stress testing.
- Improve regulatory treatment of nonperforming/restructured loans and monitoring of loan-loss migrations; encourage sustainable restructuring of nonperforming loans.
- Enhance liquidity regulations to incentivize longer deposit maturities and ensure banks do not weaken short-term foreign currency liquidity buffers further.
- Crisis management and AML/CFT:
- Develop resolution options enabling closure of failed banks, reform the National Institute for the Guarantee of Deposits (NIGD) into an operationally independent agency funded by bank premiums, increase deposit insurance coverage levels, and ensure preferential treatment for insured depositors and the NIGD.
- Strengthen the AML/CFT framework in line with the 2016 FSAP advice.
Policy priorities — structural reforms
- Competitiveness and productivity:
- External balance weaker than fundamentals imply, pointing to underlying productivity and competitiveness issues.
- Structural reforms needed to lower the cost of doing business and improve services, especially electricity, to promote jobs and strengthen social safety nets.
- Electricity sector reform:
- Electricity identified as Lebanon’s most pressing bottleneck and a significant fiscal drain.
- Reform focus: expand capacity and eliminate subsidies.
- Opportunity exists to begin raising tariffs up to cost‑recovery levels while expanding capacity and protecting vulnerable consumers given relatively low oil prices.
- Benefits: significant budget savings, elimination of private generator costs, reduced business costs, and more efficient consumption.
- Combine fiscal adjustment with expansion of social assistance to mitigate impacts on low-income households.
- Anti‑corruption and governance:
- Strengthen and operationalize the regulatory framework to fight corruption:
- Passage of whistleblower protection legislation.
- Make the illicit wealth law more effective by making asset declaration system for senior public officials (and their family members and associates) public, with audits.
- Require banks to control and report suspicious activities related to politically exposed persons.
- Establish and adequately resource the planned anti-corruption body with enforcement powers.
- Enhance fiscal transparency by strengthening governance in revenue and customs administrations, improving revenue compliance, making procurement transparent, and introducing an external audit agency.
Data and statistical improvements
- Improve data quality to enhance access to international investment and evidence-based policymaking:
- Improve quality, frequency, and timeliness of national accounts and balance of payment statistics.
- Frequently collect and publish data on employment, unemployment, and wages.
- Enhance trade in goods and services data and improve indicators monitoring economic activity.
- Strengthen inter-agency dialogue and sharing of information.
IMF staff concluding statement, Article IV mission to Lebanon (February 1–12, 2018).