A Compass to Prosperity: The Next Steps of Euro Area Economic Integration
IMF News, March 26, 2018
Source details
- Canonical URL
- A Compass to Prosperity: The Next Steps of Euro Area Economic Integration
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Christine Lagarde
- Published: March 26, 2018
Context and overview
- Speaker: Christine Lagarde, IMF Managing Director; event: German Institute for Economic Research, Berlin, Germany; March 26, 2018.
- Cyclical backdrop and macro projections:
- Global growth at 3.9 percent.
- IMF projecting 2.2 percent growth in the euro area in 2018.
- Strategic framing:
- The euro area can serve as a "compass to prosperity" — a source of global stability and a demonstration of effective international cooperation.
- Measured by GDP, the euro area has the same economic power as China.
- Measured by population, the euro area is slightly larger than the United States.
Lessons of success and crisis
- Achievements since inception:
- Creation and expansion of the monetary union; IMF support from the Maastricht Treaty onward.
- New institutions and crisis responses, including the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) and decisive ECB action (commitment to do “whatever it takes”).
- Crisis-era interventions and scale:
- Between 2010 and 2016, the ESM and its predecessor provided over 250 billion euros in loans to five countries hit hardest by the crisis.
- Remaining limitations and risks:
- Gaps persist in resilience, financial-sector security, and fiscal policy frameworks.
- Historic experience: fiscal tightening between 2011-2013 exacerbated weaknesses and contributed to a double-dip recession.
- Imperative: “repair the roof when the sun is shining” — use the current upswing to complete the architecture.
The next steps of euro area economic integration — three priority reform areas
- Overarching objective:
- Strike the right balance between “risk-sharing” and “risk-reduction” by increasing mutual trust and accountability across members.
- a) Capital Markets Union (CMU)
- Purpose: provide businesses a wider range of domestic and cross-border finance options and reduce private-sector reliance on banks.
- Recent progress:
- Legislation to improve access to financing for SMEs through high-quality loan securitizations; these instruments will operate on a level playing-field with similar types of assets.
- A new “prospectus” regulation that standardizes information and streamlines administrative procedures to help smaller companies raise capital.
- Brexit implications:
- Potential influx of financial services to continental Europe will require enhanced regulation and upgraded oversight arrangements.
- Further proposals to advance CMU:
- More transparent bankruptcy rules to improve investor recovery chances.
- Better harmonized insolvency laws and business continuity plans to promote cross-border investment.
- Expected outcome: developing capital markets to stimulate growth region-wide.
- b) Banking Union
- Progress to date:
- Creation of a single supervisor for banks.
- Introduction of a new framework for handling bank failures and new crisis-management tools.
- Important remaining gaps:
- Lack of a common deposit insurance scheme.
- Absence of a shared fiscal backstop for the Single Resolution Fund.
- Rationale for common deposit insurance and backstop:
- Would allow costs of bank failures to be shared across the euro area, reducing risk of banking-sector problems turning into sovereign debt crises (example: Cyprus in 2013).
- Resilience indicators:
- Euro area banks have nearly doubled their capital buffers since 2007.
- Non-performing loans have been reduced by more than 100 billion euros in the past year alone.
- Suggested conditionality and actions:
- In return for a common deposit scheme, banks with high levels of non-performing loans should commit to aggressive balance-sheet cleanup, using action plans with concrete timetables.
- Banks should continue building capital during the upswing to absorb future losses.
- Political timing:
- The upcoming June European Council meetings (as of March 26, 2018) provide an opportunity to discuss a common backstop to the Single Resolution Fund, a schedule for common deposit insurance, and a roadmap for reducing banking-sector vulnerabilities.
- Long-run destination:
- A safer banking system across Europe that is self-insured, does not rely on sovereign implied guarantees, and does not fall back on taxpayers.
- c) Central Fiscal Capacity
- Motivation:
- Monetary policy carried much of the burden during the last crisis; pro-cyclical fiscal tightening worsened outcomes.
- A central fiscal capacity would supplement national fiscal efforts, help prevent crisis transmission, smooth cycles, and improve currency-union functioning when monetary policy is constrained.
- Proposed design (summary of IMF staff proposal):
- Create a “rainy-day fund” that countries contribute to each year to build assets in good times.
- In downturns, countries receive transfers depending on the depth of the shock; in extreme circumstances the fund could borrow, with borrowing repaid by future member contributions.
- Transfers conditioned on member compliance with EU fiscal rules to incentivize fiscal prudence and reforms.
- Countries pay a premium in good times based on the benefits they would receive in bad times to avoid permanent transfers.
- Quantitative illustration from the staff paper:
- For a relatively modest cost — 0.35% of GDP per year — a central fiscal capacity could reduce the negative effects on output by more than 50 percent in a large euro area-wide shock when monetary policy is constrained.
- Country-specific shocks would be cushioned by nearly as much.
- Political economy considerations:
- Concerns about moral hazard and permanent transfers are acknowledged; the proposal embeds conditionality and contribution-premiums to mitigate these concerns.
- Adoption will be politically difficult; views differ significantly among members.
Policy recommendations and near-term priorities
- Use the current expansion to complete institutional architecture and build resilience.
- Advance reforms in parallel to couple risk-sharing with credible risk-reduction:
- Accelerate CMU measures: harmonize insolvency rules, strengthen prospectus standards, and prepare oversight for post-Brexit financial flows.
- Strengthen the banking union: pursue a common backstop for the Single Resolution Fund, agree on a timetable for common deposit insurance, and enforce bank balance-sheet cleanup with concrete timetables.
- Establish a central fiscal stabilization capacity with:
- Annual contributions to a rainy-day fund.
- Transfer rules conditioned on compliance with fiscal rules.
- Premiums in good times tied to expected benefits to limit permanent transfers.
- Leverage political opportunities (e.g., European Council discussions) to build consensus on backstops, deposit insurance, and roadmaps for vulnerability reduction.
- Emphasize accountability: require stronger national policies and reforms in exchange for mutual insurance mechanisms.
Conclusion and public sentiment
- Public support:
- In a recent poll, 74 percent of respondents in the euro area said they support a European economic and monetary union with one single currency — the highest number ever recorded.
- Among all Europeans surveyed, 71 percent said the region was a place of stability in a troubled world.
- Closing message:
- Improving the euro area architecture will require creativity, compromise, and patience.
- The IMF remains optimistic about the ability of European integration to deliver a more resilient and prosperous euro area.
As Prepared for Delivery by Christine Lagarde, IMF Managing Director; German Institute for Economic Research, Berlin, Germany; March 26, 2018.