Euro Area: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Mission on Common Policies for Member Countries
IMF News, December 6, 2021
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Euro Area: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2021 Mission on Common Policies for Member Countries
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: December 6, 2021
Executive summary and near-term outlook
- Forceful policies over the last year supported household disposable incomes, maintained worker-job relationships, provided credit, and protected corporate balance sheets, underpinning a strong rebound through higher private consumption and investment.
- Output fell by about 6½ percent in 2020 and rebounded strongly since 2021Q2.
- Staff baseline forecasts referenced: 5.0 percent growth for 2021 and 4.3 percent for 2022, with the possibility of modest revisions in the January WEO Update.
- Flash Q3 GDP came in slightly stronger than expected in the October 2021 WEO baseline; Q4 looks weaker due to supply pressures, elevated energy prices, and renewed mobility restrictions.
- Recovery likely uneven across countries and sectors, with risks of increasing inequality and disparities.
- Labor market: slack expected to continue declining; hours worked increasing; participation and employment rates slowly converging to pre-pandemic trends.
Risks and inflation dynamics
- High uncertainty tied to pandemic evolution and legacies.
- Downside risks: ongoing waves, newer/more transmissible variants, decreased vaccine effectiveness, incomplete vaccination coverage, expiration of policy support, real estate corrections, spillovers from a sharp slowdown in China.
- Upside possibilities: faster-than-expected adjustment to Covid-19, unwinding of large excess savings boosting consumption, pandemic-induced acceleration of automation and digitalization raising productivity and potential growth.
- Recent inflation readings: November flash estimates showed headline and core inflation around 5 and 2½ percent, respectively.
- Under the baseline, inflation projected to decline through 2022 and remain below the ECB’s 2-percent target in the medium term, predicated on limited second-round effects given persistent aggregate labor market slack.
- Negotiated nominal wages grew at about 1½ percent in 2021Q3 year-on-year.
- Inflation risks are tilted to the upside if transitory factors persist; upcoming wage negotiations need close monitoring.
Fiscal policy guidance
- Policy coordination of fiscal, monetary, and financial sector policies remains key; sequencing and speed of normalization should consider interactions across policies.
- Fiscal stance:
- Should remain supportive but become increasingly targeted as recovery continues.
- Broad lifelines such as job retention schemes should be scaled back as private consumption and labor markets strengthen; support should focus on most affected sectors and households.
- Countries should calibrate fiscal positions to country-specific circumstances.
- Once expansion is firmly in train, high-debt countries need to gradually rebuild fiscal buffers.
- Credible medium-term consolidation plans should be announced now.
- Improving composition of spending can create space for public investments to increase potential growth and accelerate green and digital transitions while bringing deficits down.
- Fiscal framework reform:
- Current rules would require unrealistically large adjustments by some high-debt countries.
- Deep consultation needed to find political consensus; time-bound transitional arrangement desirable until new rules become effective (general escape clause expected to be deactivated in 2023).
- Strengthening national fiscal councils, the European Fiscal Board, and national medium-term budget frameworks recommended.
- A green investment fund at the EU level highlighted as an efficient way to finance cross-border climate investments.
Next Generation EU (NGEU) and RRPs
- NGEU can speed recovery, facilitate resource reallocation, and address divergence among EU countries by supporting potential growth and cushioning drag from future spending restraint.
- Tradeoff for policymakers: disbursing funds rapidly versus ensuring investments and reforms are high-quality and align with implementation capacity; adherence to transparency and accountability standards is necessary.
- Preliminary IMF staff analysis suggests implementation of RRPs could expand euro area value-added by about 1¼ percent by 2026.
- RRPs play significant roles in supporting green and digital transitions.
Monetary policy stance and ECB issues
- With underlying inflation dynamics expected weak over medium term, ECB should look through transitory inflation pressures and maintain a highly accommodative stance.
- ECB needs to clarify how monetary support will be maintained when the Pandemic Emergency Purchase Program and TLTRO III are phased out.
- ECB should stand ready to scale down and terminate asset purchases and TLTROs, followed by gradual policy rate adjustment, if high inflation proves durable.
- Monetary Policy Strategy Review conclusions:
- Formal adoption of a symmetric 2-percent inflation target removes previous ambiguity and clarifies approach to temporary overshooting.
- Strengthened link between monetary and financial analysis supports holistic approach to stretched asset prices.
- Climate-related measures—enhanced monitoring, stress testing, and disclosures—recommended for supervisors and banks.
- Potential inclusion of owner-occupied housing costs into HICP price index noted; improving timeliness of construction and house price indices should be explored.
- Scope for greener central bank policies requires careful analysis given limited market depth for “green assets.”
Financial sector resilience and policy normalization
- Pandemic impact on the financial sector smaller than initially feared; July EBA stress-test indicates European banks remain resilient even in an adverse scenario.
- Potential near-term vulnerabilities:
- Rise in corporate insolvencies as public guarantee schemes are lifted.
- More complete recognition of credit losses.
- Possible correction in asset values, especially in real estate markets.
- Policy recommendations:
- Banks need to maintain sizable buffers; supervisors should ensure forward-looking loss recognition and appropriate provisioning.
- Gradual normalization of crisis-related prudential accommodations per pre-announced timelines.
- Some national authorities should tighten macroprudential stance to address stretched asset valuations and elevated household debt.
- Corporate policies should shift from broad liquidity support to targeted solvency support for intrinsically viable firms.
EU banking regulation, Banking Union, and capital markets
- European Commission banking package:
- Enhances supervisory powers and addresses ESG risks.
- May widen gap between EU capital regulations and Basel III standards due to long phase-in periods for certain exposures.
- Timely and faithful implementation of internationally agreed bank capital standards recommended.
- Renewed push for Banking Union completion urged:
- Improvements in bank supervision and resolution essential for a single market for bank services.
- Common European deposit insurance would enhance cross-border risk sharing and help banks respond to low profitability and digitalization challenges.
- Capital Markets Union progress remains important; single access point for corporate information should be advanced.
Structural reforms, labor markets, and climate policy
- Structural priorities:
- Support digital and green transitions.
- Shift labor market policies toward facilitating reallocation: expand training, reskilling, upskilling; consider hiring subsidies; temporary targeted wage-loss insurance to incentivize mobility.
- Enhance targeted safety nets with greater reliance on means-testing to protect vulnerable workers.
- Implementation of structural reforms in national RRPs is a priority: green and digital transitions, public administration, governance, pension sustainability, education, healthcare.
- Strengthen insolvency and bankruptcy frameworks: address administrative constraints, establish fast-track debt restructuring procedures, increase labor and product market flexibility.
- Climate policy:
- Support for the Fit for 55 agenda noted; central role for carbon pricing while protecting vulnerable households.
- Design and phase-in of carbon border adjustment mechanism should ensure WTO compatibility.
- Additional measures: use Common Agricultural Policy to reduce agricultural greenhouse gas emissions; tighten vehicle emissions standards.
- In current energy price spike, protective measures for vulnerable households are appropriate but should not undermine green goals or European energy market strengthening.
External engagement
- EU should continue engagement with major trading partners on trade tensions and investment distortions.
- The EU-U.S. agreement on steel and aluminum tariffs is an important step toward de-escalation.
- Prompt resolution of technical issues to finalize proposed global corporate minimum income tax is anticipated.
- EU should continue efforts to increase global vaccine production to help end the pandemic.
IMF Communications Department — December 6, 2021